What would happen if TNA an WWE switched writers?

Question

who would be champ(s)?
who would be fired?
who would be re-hired?
PS: i no writers dont sign/fire people but if they did.

Answer 1

Orton, Batista, Benjamain - Samoa Joe

Nobody

RVD, Sabu.

Answer 2

Ok here is the just if the whole thing Tna would tottally suck and WWE would be brought back from this lackluster crap it's doing right now . As far as Tna Know the good ol boys of the WWF oops I mean E . Kurt Angle would be champ for like 4 yrs and be a face again christain would never be used. Sting would be wrestling until he is at least 75 . No more lockdown pay per view or ultimate x match unless it is like once every 12 yrs and involves the same wrestlers every time. Samoa Joa would become a screaming dope who never talks . Jeff Jarret would come out every other week and tell someone (which I have to admit is rather funny) YOUR FIIIIIRED!!!!!and also no more good matches every shown on impact and last thing everyone who is a heel must always cheat to win.

Now onto the WWE they would have a lot of great matches . first they would get rid of this two brands thing. SO you would have great rivalries that actually utilizes the talent on the roster the champ wouldn't stay the same and they would give ip and comers like MVP title shots imagine a pay per views of only hell in a cell ,elimination chamber matches and TLC's Batista and lashley would have a rivalry they would brign back factions that actually work and give play too people like Kennedy and the cruiser weight division would be actually what is is susposed to be a high flying weight class that matter with people like mysterio and Rvd waging war. Flair would be fired if he didnt except a manager's or announcing position. No more Hornswaggle or bringing old legends to have matche every other yr either your in or your out. Goldberg would be brought back to have matches against the likes of Khali and Umaga . Vince would not always have his nose in every thing and the tag team and every other minor title would mean something again. No more Ecw so most of their wresltlers would be fired except for those who can actually compete. You have pay per views with matches like Vince vs Lashley that stuff is a joke.


In the End the WWE would be back like it shold not some old boring predictable crap and Tna would.

Answer 3

First off, both writing staffs would have to take into consideration where each company left off.

Second, I believe WWE would lose out on it ultimately. If we look at it this way, WWE has separate staffs for SmackDown and RAW (from what I know), so putting them together to work on one two-hour show could bring TNA up. However, the biggest problem is the X-Division, which I believe would be buried by the WWE writers. Also, I believe about half of the female wrestlers would become valets.

In the case of the WWE, I think WWE would be screwed over, and the shows would become worse. However, the cruiserweght championship would come back. A majority of storylines would be dropped, and a lot of older main-eventers would be favored to be champion over anyone else.

Answer 4

If WWE got TNA's writing staff, they'd regress to 1997. Seriously, people say they loved the Attitude Era, and yet, they can't come to terms with the New Age Outlaws and the Dudleys running the tag division scene while Dustin Rhodes is off in some dark corner doing perverted stuff with a rat while Kevin Nash stands in the back and helps book for the night. I hate to tell you "fans" but that was pretty much the Attitude Era.

In WWE, odds are Flair would be world champ, or any given member of DX. The Majors would be tag champs on Smackdown (let's face it, up until Sunday, they were as generic as the Naturals) Londrick would be holding down the Raw tag division. The Cruiserweight title would be active, but have limitless contenders...so we'd end up seeing Umaga v. Rey Mysterio for the Cruiser gold. US would still be on Porter, IC would still be on Jeff. Jeff Jarrett would be hired and put in the catbird seat to run Raw, Monty Brown would be brought back in to be his lackey, like in 04. Nora Greenwald and Gail Kim would be brought in for the woman's division, along with talented japanese imports. Khali would be fired, Big Daddy V would become a main event jobber prone to taking sick bumps

Meanwhile, in TNA, the X Division title would be turned into a rarely booked upper midcard title, if not dropped altogether. Nash would be fired, Raven would be fired, Kaz would be majorly unpushed, Matt Morgan would become a studdering full-time wrestler, and would feud with Tomko over the world title. Abyss would destroy the X Division, Rhino would still be underused, Christian would be underused, the Machine Guns would be underused. X Division guys wouldn't be allowed to go off of the top rope, Ultimate X would cease to exist Knockouts would be used as Vallets and eye candy. The championship would be around So Cal Val's waist.

It would be a disaster for both sides.

Answer 5

Vince Russo hate him or love him would bring back the 2nd coming of the attitude era... in the WWE because he is the creator of the Attitude Era...Neither Cena nor Batista would be champs ever again because Russo doesnt care what little kids want...Kennedy as a face would be a possible champion...maybe Y2J....orton and edge would be main heels....kane would finally get that push....Nobody would would prob get fired or re hired....

TNA would eventually fall until Jarret took control of creative and stay above water for a little bit but would eventually go bandrupt

excellent question : stared

Answer 6

1 Raw: Y2J or Mrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr. Kennedy....Kennedy
SD: Kane
ECW: Shelton
TNA: Since the WWE writers are used to Vince liking big guys, probably Kevin Nash

2. Fired: WWE: Todd Grisham or whatever his name is
Fired: TNA: Don West
3. Re-HiredWWE: RVD, Sabu
Re-Hired TNA: can't think of anyone

Answer 7

For WWE, I think the title fued will be between Melina, Candice, Beth, Torrie, and Mickie. Deuce and Domino/Jesse Festus/Miz and Morrison fued for tag team titles there. London Kendrick Cade Murdoch Santino Carlito(new) for those titles. I think that Drew Mcintyre would get a huge push, and the Rated R major faction would remain. I think that Kelly Kelly would be demoted and Layla would be sent to training. John Cena would have to change his gimmick or get fired. Y2J/Randy Orton/HHH/HBK fued for the WWE title. Kane would probably turn heel and get the Heavyweight championship. Chavo/Punk/Burke/Thorn fued for ECW title