Who is a better player Ken Griffey JR. Or Derek Jeter?

Question

Who do you think is better??

Answer 1

Derek Jeter without even saying so..Derek Jeter has been on of the best players in baseball, world S, champion and not hurt all that much at all. Ken Griffey Jr has been hurt many times and out of the line up. He probably could of been one of the great players or hitters in baseball. But I rather have NY Derek J on my team anytime.

Answer 2

You can not compare Jeter to Griffey Jr that is apples to oranges.....They are two totaly different players one is a shortstop the other plays the outfield.....Griffey Jr hits for power Jeter is a contact hitter.....Jr has been hampered by injury for the last 5 seasons Jeter has only had one major injury.....Jeter has 4 World Series also He has won the American League Rookie of the Year Award, a Silver Slugger Award, and three Gold Glove Awards. In 2000, he became the only player to win both the All-Star Game MVP Award and the World Series MVP Award in the same year.Rings Griffey Jr has 0 .Griffey was selected as an all-time Gold Glove winner, on a list of nine players are considered the greatest defensive players in the last fifty years.... 9-time American League Golden Glove winner, the 1992 All-Star Game MVP, 1997 AL MVP, 1998 ESPY co-winner for Male Athlete of the Year, and was named to the All-Century team in 1999.
2005 were the most he has played since 2000. Griffey's resurgence was recognized when he was named National League Comeback Player of the Year. He played in the World Baseball Classic for the American team that offseason.
JR has 593 career HRs

Answer 3

Early in his career Ken Griffey Jr. was on his way to becoming maybe the best player in the history of the game. Injures have definetly put an end to that but Jeters age and his recent preformance are obivous blemishes on his career. Right now would say that Griffey is better as long as he can stay injury free.

Answer 4

Thats not even close, Griffey and Jeter arent even in the same class IMO. Had it not been for injuries Griffey would have gone down as a top 3 ball player of all time. But even with the injuries i still have him as a top 10 player.

Griffey was a .300 hitter until his injuries, now he is still a career .290 hitter with 593 HR's and 1701 RBI's and will finish his career with prob. 650 or more HR's. Jeter is a .317 hitter (which will only get worse as he gets older) with just 195 HR's and 933 RBI's. Thats not even comparable. Not to mention Griffey was one of the greatest defensive CF's of all time, Willie Mays like. Jeter is one of the worst defensive SS's in the game...

Answer 5

Derek Jeter

Answer 6

Griffey substitute into easily a good fielder at one factor (Jeter has never been a good fielder, as a results of fact of his adverse variety), and alter right into a plenty extra desirable hitter for the time of his best. Jeter is an marvelous hitter for a shortstop, of course, besides as an marvelous baserunner over a excellent occupation. i'm nevertheless going with Griffey. although, not all skills are created equivalent - i will take a brilliant hitter who's mediocre interior the sphere and on the bases than somebody who's only respectable at each little thing.

Answer 7

They play different positions. You can't really compare them. Jeter can hit for average, and Griffey is a better power hitter. However, I am more of a fan of Jeter than Griffey.

Answer 8

As of right now, Derek Jeter is the better player.

Griffey before his injuries was awesome!
Before injuries, i would say Griffey was the better player, but not by much.

Answer 9

My opinion is Jeter.

Jeter has a higher lifetime batting average, while Griffey definitely has more power. But he can't seem to stay healthy and all of that power does nothing when he is sitting on the bench.

Answer 10

Well when griffey was in his younger years he was amazing but now adays he has lost a step or too so i would have to go with the Shortstop Jeter