The People Who Support Guantanamo Bay?

Question

do you also support Hitlers camps which he kept the jews in terrible condition???

Answer 1

I totally agree with you -- and guess what I am not Muslim !!

"The Saint" especially for you: Hitler accused the poor Jews of crimes they hadn't committed, didn't he ? Some parallel here, then ? So... why the double standards, chum ?!

Answer 2

the 2 are not the same. the Jews had not done anything wrong Hitler just used them as a scape goat.
on the other hand people in Guantanamo bay where picked up in wars zones Afghanistan, Iraq they had done some wrong either they were members of the Taliban or terrorist groups and had killed or where planning to kill.
don't compare the Hitler to bush that's just silly and without foundation

Answer 3

I am so surprised at the ignorant people who answered this question. They seem to think only those people who are guilty are at that awful place. There are many people who are innocent that are there and the only reason is because they are Muslim. And if anyone is stupid enough to believe they are being treated in any kind of civilized manner then the media has obviously warped your minds. Yes many of the people there are guilty and deserve to be there, but unfortunately they are not the only ones there. I wonder how many people here realize that even if they are Americans, if the govt. thought you were guilty of something you could end up there too with no rights whatsoever, not even the right to legal counsel.

Answer 4

F uck off to Afghanistan with your neo conism bullshit and go bury your head in the sand......................
DONT equate Guantamo BAy with what Hitler did YOU SICK FUCKE R. HOW DARE YOU EQUATE THE TWO????
You dont give a **** about Jews anyway, no matter how you dress it up with saying, "show me the proof where I said that", just like a snotty nosed brat who needs his ar se slapping. GET A LIFE, you spent your 19th birthday on here for Gods sake, how saddo is that?????
I support G bay, keeps Muslim extremists from blowing up innocent people. Its not a religion anymore Islam, is it,??? its a political cause or party. Fanaticism, terrorism.

Answer 5

The two are unrelated and serve/served completely different purposes.

You should learn more about the Holocaust before throwing it into a question out of context in an attempt to make a feeble point about an unrelated issue.

Most people on here probably have you sussed by now Kamran as a naive, bigoted anti-American with blinkers on who is constantly trying to score points for your pro-Islamic agenda with the rather simplistic approach of :-

Islamic= good and above criticism
Western/Jewish/American/Christian =bad, decadent, always wrong.

I suggest you wait until you leave school and have lived in the real world for a bit before tackling such weighty issues.

I could ask....The people who condemn Guantanamo Bay.

Do you want to see murderers and terrorists freed to commit more cowardly, inhuman crimes against innocent children and families ?

But I'm not that naive.

Answer 6

Do you actoually know what took place in Hitler's camps? Apparently not if you're making this comparison. The prisoners in Cuba never had it so good. If you're lucky, that's where you'll end up when whichever plot you're dreaming up gets foiled.

Answer 7

If the so-called war on terror is about protecting “the American way of life” and “democracy” then by carrying out acts of torture in Guantanamo they lose that war. They engage in precisely the sort of behaviour they themselves condemn and sacrifice the very values that they claim to be fighting for. Carrying out acts of torture does not only humiliate, degrade or destroy the victim, it utterly degrades the society that condones it.

In condemning torture, for whatever purpose, one does not put oneself on the side of the terrorists or “makes excuses” for their actions, but rather recognises that we should not allow for the ultimate degradation of our own society by stooping to the level of those we condemn.The inmates of Guantanamo Bay are not even afforded the basic right of answering the condemnation in a court of law.Americans need to face up to the fact that they torture people and quite possibly innocent people at that.

When the concentration camps were liberated at the end of the second world war.Germans from nearby towns were taken to see for themselves the horrors wrought upon the innocent, mostly Jewish, people.Denial turned to shame.Is this Americas destiny?Waking up to the reality that they have lost their soul.

Answer 8

I support making the entire Middle East, except for Israel, into one giant Guantanamo Bay. A big barbed wire fence around the whole entire sh*thole. How do you like that?

Answer 9

Whether I support it or not is irrelevant but the big difference is that the jews in the camps weren't likely to go around blowing up everything to do with the western world.
Red Chrome - Please tell me what each detained group would be more than willing to do upon release? Rebuild their lives or resume terrorism/connections with.

Answer 10

only americans could support that place because they are brainwashed into believing that its right. those people are there without trial. but people like " a human bean " thinks thats good.
guantanamo bay is a disgrace. it should be closed down and the government that opened it and supports it should be prosecuted.

Answer 11

Both are examples of human rights being abused to a huge extent. Amnesty International has taken note of its human right abuses.