Can i house a betta in a setup like this?? READ DETAILS??

Question

I have a large vase and i have nothing to use it for. My niece suggested putting a betta in it. But i have not had any experience with betta fish before. Only goldfish and other tropical fish. The vase is pretty big, 45 cm tall with a 30 cm diameter. The vase is not a fish bowl it is a cylinder shape similar to this http://www.michaelcfina.com/images/products/full/GLLENOLADOG003.jpg but much bigger of course and without the spot things. Would it be suitable for a betta or is it cruel? Also should i put an air stone in it for more oxygen or does it not need one?

I dont think the vase is suitable i think i will just put flowers in it. But i am still hooked on getting a betta. Would a something like this be better http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=3635102

Answer 1

yeah you could but its better off to have them in a big tank

Answer 2

Vases don't make the best homes for bettas. Adding an airstone will provide some dissolved oxygen, but this doesn't provide for correct water temperature. Bettas are tropical fish, and should be kept in a water temperature of 76-86o.

Betta vases were quite popular a few years back, but the producers of these never considered the needs of the fish - temperature and filtration are just two factors. Manufacturers led people to believe that the fish would eat the roots of the plants (they don't - they're carnivores), and that the plant would remove all wastes from the water, so you never had to change the water for the fish (another bad idea).

While bettas are great fish that don't require a lot of space, a betta should have at least 2.5 gallons per fish, a heater, and a gentle filter. I keep mine in setups like this one: http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=3635102 - these come with a filter, light, and tank, so you just need to get a heater and decor.

Answer 3

A betta is an anabantid and takes 90% of its oxygen from the water's surface so an air stone is not necessary when keeping bettas. This ability to live in unaerated water is, unfortunately, a major selling point for pet retailers because it's easy to convince people that miniscule containers (I've seen them housed in martini glasses!) are adequate for them. This is not an ideal setting for bettas because they are tropical fish, not decorative gems. The vase would be better for a houseplant or for layering colored gravel/sand as an accent piece.

If you'd like to keep a betta, you really need at least a 2.5 gallon tank (a 5 or 10 gallon would be better) so that it can easily be heated and filtered. Many people house these fish in mere bowls, but judging from the many questions listed here on Y! Answers, these setups are obviously detrimental to the fish made to live in them. Bettas are tropical and require temps of 76-85 F. Anything below 75 F is too cool and leads to dietary and health problems in the fish. Unless you're living in the tropics, these fish must have a heater and it's simply not safe to attempt to heat a container like this because it would be too easy to overheat and cook the fish.


Edit to add:
The 2.5g minibow would be a suitable home. Pick up a mini heater and thermometer as well and keep the tank's temp above 75 degrees (F). Ideally, bettas should be kept in the upper 70s to mid 80s.

Answer 4

You should give your Betta the best home possible. Who would want to live in a tiny cup, or somewhere that has not enough space? I wouldn't. They have 10 gallon tanks at walmart for $9.99. For a tank that large your going to need a heater and a filter. It's the best thing for the fishy. I don't think the vases are a good idea it's not enough room for them to swim in. It's cruel, for a Betta to live in a vase. Good Luck

Answer 5

In my opinion, bowls are for candy and vases are for flowers. Fish need to be in tanks with adequate filtration and heat (as necessary).

Regarding your particular vase, the height would intimidate a betta as they breathe directly from the air. An air stone is entirely unnecessary for a betta. Also, bettas need water in the 75F - 82F and this requires a heater. Vases and bowls of any sort are not well suited for commercially available heaters.

It would simply be cruel to put a betta in that vase, please don't:(

Answer 6

Bettas, like each fish, prefer a various weight loss software to stay healthy. this is the fairly some issues I feed my bettas: 3 distinctive styles of Betta pellets, freeze dried bloodworms, frozen bloodworms, frozen daphnia, stay brine shrimp, solar dried shrimp, stay mosquito larvae. commerce meals and don't feed an identical factor each and all the time. The extra wealthy meals (like bloodworms and mosquito larva) must be used as a manage or used to subject breeding bettas. Feeding a mashed pea as quickly as a week additionally helps save their digestive music so as (so does the daphnia).

Answer 7

Bettas need at least a 5-gallon tank with a heater to thrive. A filter is best to maintain good water quality without the stress associated with constant water changes.
Please use your vase for a beautiful flower arrangement!
If you do decide to get a betta, please check out this site:
http://www.peteducation.com:80/article.cfm?cls=16&cat=1911&articleid=2340
BTW, just because bettas can survive in small spaces, doesn't mean they should have to. Bettas do not live in tiny puddles in nature as is widely reported, they live in rice paddies. Also, they can live for up to 10 years. 5-7 years is more common in good captive conditions, but no one should be patting themselves on the back for having a betta live 2 years.

Answer 8

We have a betta in a glass vase, it is a fairly good sized vase. It has a plant on the top and its roots go into the water. We put in a bit of gravel in the bottom and our betta seems very happy! You don't have to heat a tank with a beta, but at the same time they don't want freezing cold water.

Our betta has lasted 4 years in the vase and is still going strong! He seems rather happy. He blows bubbles regularly.

Answer 9

The tank you linked too, is the perfect size for a betta
just buy a 7.5 watt heater as well when you get the tank
as well as live plants, they love to rest on them

but definately stay away from these vases




Hope that helps
Good luck



EB

Answer 10

You have a very creative idea. that's one big vase you got there. In the wild, bettas live in a very shallow water like buffalo'shoofprints. Half full of water is enough room for a betta and have heater ready as you need it in winter time. Betta is air breather. You don't need air stone in the vase, air bubbles disturb water and that stress out betta fish.

Answer 11

I would put a betta in one, for I have two, I just love this type of fish, you are able to put in the vase colour stones, shells, or even a plant, with just the roots showing, make sure thou that the roots of the plant are well cleaned, some bettas can be put into a fish tank with all the equipment, but a betta can be put into a vase, without the air pumps. You must also clean the vase at least once a week, and feed them twice a day, I crush the pellets, for I find that my fish eat it more easliy. Remember a female betta and a male betta have to be seperated and no two male betta's together. Enjoy they are a beautiful fish to watch.