Which is more deadly, a hurricane or a tornado?

Question

im doing a project in my earth space science class. the project is a debate with a hurricane survivor and a tornado survivor. and i have to give a long speech on both occurences. which is more deadly, a hurricane or a tornado?

Answer 1

You're comparing apples and oranges.

If you're comparing two people who are both directly in the storms' paths, the tornado is worse.
If you're comparing the total area of devastation, and the total number of fatalities, a hurricane is worse.

This is an oversimplified explanation but a tornado is really a very compressed, localized hurricane.

And guess what weather phenomenon kills the most people worldwide? It's not hurricanes, tornadoes, floods or blizzards. It's heat waves.

Answer 2

A Tornado, Let me explain, Tornadoes are extreamly unpredictable, I know because I have been chasing them for the past eight years. There is little understanding about how a tornado actually works and forms, we have a good idea, but the sheer statistics of a tornado are still undetermined. No one has been able to get accurate enough data to find out about what goes on in the lower 100ft of a twister and that is where we believe the majority of what is needed to predict and examine a tornado happens. A tornado's path is never stable, or stright. It can veer all over the place, making it hard to predict. They can last minutes, or hours. Hurricanes, have a much better warning system, it also helps that they can be seen by GOES which is the weather satelite, but tornadoes can not. Yes you have the winds and the storm surge of a hurricane, but you have the unpredictable-ness and the greater wind speeds of a tornado. I hope this helps you some what.

Answer 3

Hurricanes usually cause more damage... They are bigger and effect a larger area then a tornado, which can come and go in min's or hours...

But a winter blizzard is actually more deadly then both a hurricane and a tornado combined...

The Blizzard that hit back in 1993 was 2x as big and caused more damage to a much larger area of the US then Hurricane Katrina... It just took longer and didn't have the "minority's" screaming about discrimination to bring the issue the type of attention that the Hurricane Katrina did.

Go and look up the stats on the 1993 blizzard... It will bring a whole new perspective to the debate.

Answer 4

Probably a hurricane. A tornado has faster wind speed, but the storm is far smaller, so the damage is limited. Tornados also tend to have shorter lives than hurricanes. Tornados completely destroy everything in a narrow path. A hurricane does moderate to severe damage over thousands of square miles.

One other way huricanes damage property is the tidal surge pushed up by the wind. A massive tidal surge was what destroyed the leveys and flooded New Orleans. A single tornado can not destroy an entire city, but a hurricane can.

Answer 5

A hurricane is more deadly because it covers such a large spread area. Tornados are very strong but do not cover a that large of an area. Hurricanes also hit the coasts, which the populations are higher than in towns in the mid west.

Answer 6

Hurricane

Answer 7

More deaths have been attributed to hurricanes than to tornadoes, although you do not want to experience either one. Hurricanes often spawn tornadoes when they cross onto land. Hurricanes expend a great deal more energy than a tornado. They last longer, are bigger, and result in wind damage, flood damage, and other severve weather damage that tornadoes do but on a much smaller time and space scale.

Answer 8

there are a number of factors which equate into whether a typhoon or twister would be greater deadly than one yet another. One ingredient, unsurprisingly, is the intensity of the typhoon as against the intensity of the twister. yet another ingredient is how super of a community the typhoon or twister outcomes. the familiar typhoon is a hundred miles in diameter, mutually as a twister can selection from merely some toes in diameter to over a mile extensive in diameter. so far as wind speeds pass, a catastrophic twister can attain lots quicker winds than a typhoon (over 3 hundred mph), mutually as the quickest typhoon wind velocity ever recorded (205 mph) grow to be from typhoon Camille in 1969. yet, a extensive ingredient is how densely populated the area is. The greater densely populated the area which the typhoon or twister strikes, the greater deaths that are possibly to ensue. If a twister hit a corn container, there may be far fewer skill fatalities than if the twister hit downtown Chicago. consequently, that is not dazzling that Bangladesh, one the the main densely populated international locations in the worldwide, holds the two the checklist for the deadliest twister and the deadliest typhoon. to boot being densely populated, Bangladesh is between the poorest worldwide locations in the worldwide and suffers from undesirable housing. Do I experience structural integrity to play a place besides? You wager. The greater structurally sound a house or development is, for particular, the greater effective the prospect a guy or woman has to stay to inform the tale. In end, a solid typhoon has greater skill to kill than a solid twister. inspite of the actuality that the winds of a solid typhoon won't in any respect tournament the winds of a solid twister, a typhoon has importance and water (from the typhoon surge) on its ingredient and would result a lots larger area than a twister. although, word how I used the word skill in sentence one. There ought to continuously be exceptions to this end. there is often the ingredient of possibility, which i like to call good fortune. as an occasion, merely this twelve months an F3 twister hit downtown St. Louis (even the airport!) and did not kill every physique. One might assume distinctive fatalities, yet destiny grow to be on their ingredient that day.

Answer 9

A hurricane. It covers a larger area.

Answer 10

In my opinion...a tornado because their is little warning. If people evacuate when they are told...the hurricane isn't as deadly.