Which do you think would have better odds of figuring out who is innocent & who is guilty in US courtrooms?

Question

Lawyers, Judges, & Juries or flipping a coin?

And if the 50/50 chance of flipping a coin is more accurate why do we need lawyers, Judges and Juries?

Answer 1

The standard of proof is guilty beyond reasonable doubt. I think juries are more likely to doubt, so will be more likely to doubt the evidence and rule not guilty, and that judges and lawyers will doubt less and so be more likely to convict, and are probably right more often. Which is better depends on your judgment of how many innocent people should be judged guilty vs how many guilty people are set free.

Answer 2

I would always want a jury of my peers. And want it for everyone. Deals are chancy and hold terrible surprises as Judges have final say even with plea bargains. I would rather have the scandal of court then agree to a "deal".

Answer 3

laywers. judges are all about the law. juries dont know enoguht about the law. but lawyers know about the law but at the same time dont only care about the law so that way you get 12 smart reasonable ppl.

Answer 4

My brother is this have been real then we'd all be condemned. God provide a heavier weight to those which will carry his be conscious. There are people who're appointed by making use of God to the dominion, and earlier they got here to the Lord that they had misplaced lives in this worldwide, and yet they continuously knew that the Lord we real. in the certainty courtroom we expect of that we cope with human beings solid, and we expect of that its o.k. to fornicate, yet did you already know which you're sinning against your very own physique and against God once you lay with somebody basically for the comparable of delight? the two being unaware of this regulation, who then is treating the different "solid?' Jesus suffered and he grow to be harmless! There are people who go through for the sake of the dominion, however the only element they actually ought to settle for is they're sinners. with the aid of fact of this we receive grace and mercy, with the aid of fact what the worldwide measures as being in charge God does no longer use the measurements of guys. In lack of understanding Paul preached against the dominion of heaven, however the scriptures says that he grow to be given grace and mercy with the aid of fact he did it unbelief! How impressive isn't it? Then he went directly to the the instructor of the destiny christians no longer merely of his time, yet for the the rest years that guy has upon this earth. God is unquestionably solid. some human beings go through with the aid of fact we are able for use for his purpose in the tip.