Which QB should I pick up and start?

Question

My league has two starting QBs my main QB is Brady but Matt Schaub my second starter is injured. So I have a list of picking up and stating in week 14 Sage Rosenfels @ Tampa, Josh McCown@ Green Bay, Brodie Croyle@ Denver, AJ Feeley@ NYGiants (Mcnabb is still out), Todd Collins@ Chicago, and last Chris Redman@NewOrleans. Who should I choose? If I win this week I clinch the last playoff spot. Thanks!

Answer 1

I would go with Chris Redmen, hehas the most upside of this bunch.
If the Flacons score, it will most likely result from a throw. If the Eagles score it most likely is because of Westbrook. I think McCown, Collins and Croyle are not worthy of being used in any fantasy format.

Answer 2

BTW I saw that McNabb is likely to play against the giants this weekend so be careful of Feeley.

Out of that list I would pick Chris Redman probably as NO have been giving a lot away in that area.

Answer 3

All the matchups you are faced with stink. If it were me I would go with Redman. He faces a dreadful Saints pass defense and has a decent receiving corps (Roddy White, Alge Crumpler and even Warrick Dunn/Jerious Norwood are good in check down passes) And just to make sure use Brady as your other starter. I think that goes without saying, but even against the steel curtain hes 42 TDs in 12 games makes him a must start no matter the match up

Answer 4

Chris Redman has huge upside against one of the worst pass defenses, but he is not proven so it is a gamble.

Answer 5

I'd go with AJ Feely. He definitely looked solid when they played at NE and if you can play there and come close to pulling out a win then you can play well anywhere..

good luck!

Answer 6

A.J. Feeley