Which eyeliner lasts longer, Liquid or Pencil???

Question

Will a liquid last longer than a pencil? and be more smudgeproof/waterproof?

Answer 1

I used both and both smudged easily. What works best for me is going and getting a super thin brush and applying black eyeshadow as eyeliner - its the most long lasting so far for me!

Answer 2

I use both and i prefer Kohl pencil.
Now I use Clinique Kohl Shaper For Eyes.
It's great and it leasts whole day and it doesn't smudge even if u cry or do some activities that cause sweting.

here r some liquid eye liners that i like:
Sephora Brand Long Lasting Eye Liner , $10
but i've also used
Lancome ARTLINER - Precision Point EyeLiner , $27
Bourjois Liquid Liner , $15.50
Lancome LE STYLO WATERPROOF - Long Lasting Eyeliner , $22
Dior Liquid Eyeliner , $30
Shiseido The Makeup Fine Eyeliner , $13 - $27
Dior Style Liner , $30
Bourjois Liner Clubbing , $16

And 4 the pencile ones:
Sephora Brand Slim Pencil - Eye , $1 - $4
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil , $15
Sephora Brand Liner Electro - Glitter Eye Pencil , $6
NARS Eye Liner Pencil , $19
Clinique Quickliner for Eyes, $14.50
Clinique Kohl Shaper For Eyes, $15.50(this is the best one!)

P.S i think I allready told u this? :P

Answer 3

Liquid def lasts longer and is generally smudgeproof. I just prefer pencil though i think it looks more natural

Answer 4

I think pencil looks more natural. I've used both and just prefer pencil.

I also get a thin brush and use black eyeshadow sometimes and make it look like a liner from a pencil or liquid.

Answer 5

In my experience, liquid holds longer, unless you get it wet and smear it with your hands of course. But other than that, stays on all day with no problems, no smudges, etc. Also it lets you get a cleaner edge, so if you are looking for the "smoky eyeliner" look I'd go with pencil

Answer 6

i prefer liquid to pencil. but have since switched to a gel type liner from bobbi brown. i never could seemingly put pencil on properly and I can get much finer line with either the gel or the liquid.

Answer 7

Liquid because the pencils have waxes and binders in them that make them smudge off

Answer 8

i've never used liquid eyeliner before. but everytime i use pencil, it smudges so i don't use eyeliner anymore. if i do, i use very little so that if it does smudge, you can't tell.

Answer 9

pencil last a lot longer

Answer 10

I'd say waterproof liquid eye liner made by Almay.....