Golden Compass, which hits theaters in December, creates a parallel world where human souls take the form of animal companions. We would advise parents not to take their children to see the film, and certainly not to buy them the books. The danger is that parents will not realize, from the film, what Pullman is promoting. Pullman's trilogy shows a world where there is no God." "The problem is that kids may see the film and ask their parents for the books," said Kiera McCaffrey, director of communications for the Catholic League. "The trilogy of books, especially the third volume, promotes atheism and denigrates Christianity. This is central to the plot. Spread the word for parents to not let their children see this film.
2007-11-27 02:18:47 · 17 answers · asked by bobe 6 in Entertainment & Music ➔ Movies
I won't be taking my kids to see the movie. I've heard the movie itself isn't that offensive but that the later books become intolerable. They end with the hero's killing God.
To the others writing in, children are exposed to plenty of other options. Exposure to other ideas is not something any child in America is going to lack. If you truly believe in Christianity, it is more important to give your children a strong foundation before you expose them to ideas they aren't ready to assimilate.
2007-11-27 02:45:13 · answer #1 · answered by LilyRT 7 · 3⤊ 3⤋
I'm taking my little brother.
I am a Christian and I read those books as a child. For me, they were great for my skills in practicing discernment, catching the messages. My parents didn't pay any attention to what I read, so I read everything from Stephen King to The Bible, and this. Here's what I think about boycotting this.
- First of all, they kill God at the end of the third book, so that will not be present in the movie
-An interview I read with the director said that he didn't put the anti-Christian stuff in, because he didn't want to alienate the Christian crowd.
-Nicole Kidman is Catholic and she said that she couldn't be in the movie if it was anti-Catholic.
So now the only danger will be in kids reading the books. Possible solutions:
-don't let your kids read the books. Tell them what is in them and say that the movie is better (the books were slow to me, especially the first one, so this is probably true)
-Read it with your child and point out the offensive material so that in the future when they read theologically offensive things, they will catch it and not fear it. Use them to teach them about God.
I don't support a boycott because we shouldn't just be advocating Christian material in the world. This is not a Christian state, and we can use this as a springboard to witness to others. Plus, I believe that the shadow proves the sunshine. God allowed evil in the world as another option, and as a comparison. They made the movie because they wanted to make money, and have courteously watered it down for us. I would reward the makers for that, so instead they don't make a fiery political movie in the future, because those are just not entertaining at all. Anyway, I will see this movie, because I'm not afraid of other ideas in the world. They provoke thought and lead to clarity. This movie and the books have as much right to thrive as Narnia.
2007-11-28 02:51:18 · answer #2 · answered by Mrs. Eric Cartman 6 · 2⤊ 1⤋
Alot of non believers didn't like prayer so prayer was taken
away in schools, they want to take God out of the Pledge
Of Allegiance, off money, etc. They say we are shoving
it down their throats.
Now it is okay for this guy who is a non believer (he
said "God died a long time ago") to shove his beliefs
on others. The guy above there said the movie does
have anti-religious themes.
So it seems like it is fine for them to protest about
the Christians but the Christians should not protest this
movie? Seems like a double standard, doesn't it?
I am suprised Kidman was in it since she claims to be
Catholic.
Well, I won't be seeing it anyway.
Edit-
I see another one up there talking about Bush again.
Why is it that some think all Christians are Republican?
Sheesh.
2007-12-01 00:45:42 · answer #3 · answered by technician 5 · 1⤊ 0⤋
I have no children of my own but i do have nieces i have mixed feelings. I'm a Christian so i do find it offensive his portrayal of God in the third installment and his anti Catholic element even though I'm not Catholic myself i don't agree with a lot of what the Church of Rome has done in history but there is many good and charitable Catholics and i think it is outrageous slur on them and there faith. I do wonder if he would have the guts to denigrate Islam in this fashion? I some how doubt it.
2007-11-27 03:52:27 · answer #4 · answered by jack lewis 6 · 2⤊ 1⤋
No they're all in their twenties now! LOL.They're all atheists already so she's too late.Anyway if she's so convinced of her Catholic faith what does she have to fear?She seems to be advocating a see no evil hear, hear no evil approach to religious teaching which amounts to brainwashing.Atheism isn't evil.They are every bit as moral as someone who worships a god.
Edit:Dramatics answer shows a much more sensible approach.Indeed it's about time we all took an interest in each others beliefs in a friendly way to promote understanding
2007-11-27 02:36:31 · answer #5 · answered by Misty Blue 7 · 3⤊ 1⤋
Ok well i'm a Christian but i think if you raised your kids with the right christian morals they would know that the movie is wrong all by themselves. If you don't let them see the other peoples view points the other people are just going to walk all over them because they wouldn't know how to defend their beleifs. I myself do not support this movie.
2007-11-28 11:56:44 · answer #6 · answered by chocolate_lover 2 · 2⤊ 1⤋
I have no children
That being said, I may NOT take me to see that film. So far, the trailers on tv have looked typically over-produced. Too much CGI and I'm outa there
Why are you Christians so afraid that if given options, people may decide to go elsewhere for their spiritual nourishment? Your attitude is why I want Bush OUT of the White House and dont want Romney in!
2007-11-27 02:29:23 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 4⤊ 3⤋
Yes, I agree w/ you. This film isn't good for kids to watch, it has bad effects on kids. Violence on shows causes psychological effects on children.
2007-11-29 13:17:38 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 1⤊ 0⤋
Every parent should do what they think is right for his or her children. You don't have to take your own kids. But don't ruin a good movie and a good story for everyone else.
2007-11-27 07:06:10 · answer #9 · answered by truefirstedition 7 · 1⤊ 1⤋
The only reason I wouldn't take kids to see it, is that the action looks pretty intense (and might be overwhelming) and that it might be a bit over their heads, not because it's "anti-Christian." As long as good morals are instilled, one make-believe movie will not affect that.
2007-11-27 02:30:04 · answer #10 · answered by dramatic_miss 2 · 6⤊ 1⤋