Palestinian Right of Return, They Should Be allowed Back?

Question

An Jewish homeland setup by the British in 1948 was illegal and created a system of Apartheid and Exclusion, the result. 4 million Palestinian refugees living in squalor and abject poverty around the middle east caused by the short sighted actions of the British and Americans. These people cannot and should not be forced to live like this any longer. There is no conclusive proof in any historical documentation that Palestine was t Hebrew land

Answer 1

Of course they should be allowed back. A bi national secular state could then be created. This would be a just solution

Answer 2

This is a very controversial issue....so I try not to take sides...

But for the sake of the argument.....

Palestinians are mostly Muslim, but there is a recognizable number of Christians. Actually the Christians put up a good fight in 1948

i think it's not about Jews, Muslims, and Christians.

It's about Palestinians and Israelis

The Palestinian "Right of Return" doesn't contradict with the "Two State" solution, but Israel has the upper hand now, and they for some reason will not allow the refugees to return. They have their concerns.

But the real Questions should be.......

What should happen to these refugees?

What will happen to the Israelis?

What is the solution for that region that will make sleep with clear consciousness?

Answer 3

While the Zionists have America backing them they can, and will, do as they like.
Their settlements in the West Bank, 'the facts on the ground', mean they never had any intention of allowing a 2 State solution.
The Palestinians have been robbed of the land, their dignity and their hope. They should be allowed back but I don't see that happenning soon.
The Israelis have allowed about one million Eastern Europeans and Russians to settle. It's enough to have one grandparent who was Jewish to allow you to go there. Remember a few months ago the Neo-Nazis who were beating up Jews? They were East Europeans.

Answer 4

There were always Jews there. A two state solution is the way forward, and the solution that most decent people agree with. You should agree with it too.

Answer 5

Why are Muslims so selfish? They already have Mecca and Medina. Why not let the Jews have their sacred land?

Answer 6

in answer to some other answerers, how would you feel if somebody kicked you out of yyour house because they used to live there?