English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

its so unlogic:

"in the beginning there was nothing, no universe no sun, no planets, no moons, no stars..nothing." And suddenly a Big Bang comes out of nowhere (how is that possible?)
exploding and creating the whole universe step by step ( how can a huge big bang, create a burning sun, a planet that can hold life, all this stars and planets, just like that, with one bang,) doesn't that sound unlogic and unpossible?

2007-11-23 10:09:00 · 13 answers · asked by Anonymous in Science & Mathematics Astronomy & Space

13 answers

Hold on for a sec....Ok I was trying to make a 5 dollar bill out of thin air. It didnt work. You probably already knew that but that is what astronomers want us to believe with the Big Bang. They say time cannot exist before this point and if it did their would be no evidence left. Out of nothing came something. Our little minds will not let us believe anything else. All the evidence that points to this had to come from somewhere and do we know that everyone who had a theory hold up over time knew what the hell they were doing at the time. We will never know the answer to this question unless GOD shouted it down from the heavens with a booming voice. But after GOD did his thing, the next logical question would be, where did you come from. And this little game will continue on and on. Or unless we find evidence that something can appear from nothing.

2007-11-23 21:49:11 · answer #1 · answered by vdfarms2003 2 · 0 1

The Big Bang is a theory used to explain our observations of the universe. You know, they didn't just pull it out of their hat, many different observations lead to the same conclusion, at least according to modern science.

Now, you say that the Big Bang came from nothing. You do not know that. You may have inferred that from your little to non-existent understanding of the theory, but there is nothing to say what, if anything, existed in what we laughingly call "before". The Big Bang is like the Ultimate Reset, if there was anything that preceded it, there can exist no evidence of what it was nor what it was like. Whatever there was before the Big Bang cannot in any way affect the universe after the Big Bang. It is a mystery, but a mystery that has been presented to us by the universe, as opposed to a random guess by an astronomer.

It is easy to see how the Big Band could lead to us. All it takes is five minutes to open up a book on the subject to answer all your questions. You may be under the impression that the Big Bang was an expplosiuon much like a bomb. Nothing could be further from the truth. Nothing you know can be compared to it. You cannot argue against it from your personal incredulity: surely you realise that just because you do not understand it, that doesn't make it untrue?

A singularity expanded and then inflated, the universe a state of pure order (homogeneous energy). Matter condensed from that energy, including particles that make up atoms. The first and most common element was and is Hydrogen, and its isotopes. A very small amount of Helium was created in the embryonic universe, and an even smaller amount of Lithium. No other elements existed.

Gravity eventually caused the Hydrogen to form distinct clouds, early galaxies. Within these clouds points became even more concentrated, and Hydrogen collapsed until it reached critical mass and began nuclear fusion- four Hydrogen nuclei fused into a Helium nucleus, and energy (in the form of electromagnetic radiation) is released by the conversion of the extra mass left over to energy, when two of those protons are converted into neutrons.

There were no planets orbiting these first generation stars. All the elements up to Iron were and are created through nuclear fusion within stars- they become red giants once the Hydrogen runs out and Helium is fused, and the star progressively fuses more and more nuclei. They die when they try to fuse Iron, which the forge of stars cannot to.

The larger stars go supernova when they try to fuse Iron, and the supernova creates even heavier elements. As this star-stuff is scattered across the galaxies, second generation stars form, but this time other elements pollute the hydrogen clouds from which they are born, as you can see, this is an increase in disorder, not order. They accrete in the disk around a forming star, becoming planets. Our sun is a third-generation star.

If a planet is the right size and sort, is at the right distance from its orbiting star and somewhat protected from inter-stellar violence (nearby supernovas, for instance) then conditions may be right for some sort of life to emerge on the planet, fuelled by the energy from the sun.


While it may seem that this is an increase in ordered structure in the universe, it is actually a march towards entropy. Pure order was homogeneous energy, entropy will occur when there is no more hydrogen to form stars and one of the predicted deaths of the universe occurs.

2007-11-23 12:36:31 · answer #2 · answered by Bullet Magnet 4 · 0 0

The Big Bang theory is just that, a theory, and remain to be proven.

When Hubble discovered the red shift on the galaxies it was presumed the the universe was expanding, thus it must have been all in one place at some point in time. When the Bell laboratories discovered the background radiation noise in telecommunications it was interpreted as the after glow of a cosmic explosion that supported Hubble's idea of a Big Bang.

In reality no one can prove the Big Bang ever happened. As said before is just a theory.

More modern models of the universe show the universe as a cob spider web where matter only exist in the web filaments. The voids are just empty space.

Imagine an aquarium full of large bubbles. Only on those lines around the bubbles where the soap collects is where matter exist. Now imagine that the bubbles are growing and the soap lines are stretching. That's the universe!

What is in the space in the center of those bubbles? What is making the bubbles expand? Your guess is as good as mine.

2007-11-23 11:58:23 · answer #3 · answered by autoglide 3 · 0 0

Since the Big Bang was the start of time and the initial expansion of space within the singularity, it is logical to argue that the universe has, in fact, existed for all time. We most certainly will never know the answer to this question and we should just accept the fact that we can't know everything. Note that this is not an acceptable reason to claim magical beings or other superstitious nonsense was involved.

2016-05-25 03:34:10 · answer #4 · answered by ? 3 · 0 0

I think it was Atoms that made the big bang and their was nothing but dark matter and a explosion came from no where and it grew and it made universe and it continues to expand to this very day. Then years later in space the big bang fromed a disc and it spined and formed the sun in the middle and the sun created planets and stars shown up natrualy then the suns gravity combine the molten rocks together to form a planet and it took 1 year for it to cool down and the volcanos erupted on earth making the earth lot bigger and a meteor hit the earth and started to form rain clouds and it rained and filled up the oceans and it took 100 years for it to fill the planet. The earth's moon was created when the earth was created as a molten rock and the earth was separated with a big molten rock and formed the moon that we know today brightning the skies at night.

2007-11-23 10:33:03 · answer #5 · answered by ? 4 · 0 1

There are several theories about how the universe began (including one that says there was never a beginning), and even though the Big Bangs seems impossible, there is plenty of evidence for it.

The question of how and why there was a Big Bang is still unanswered. There may never be an answer to those questions.

Many people confuse "unexplained" with "impossible". Don't be one of those people.

2007-11-23 10:49:29 · answer #6 · answered by John B 6 · 0 0

Physicists are now talking about M theory which says that there are an infinite number of different shaped universes in the 11th dimension. All of which have similar or completely different laws of physics and have different shapes such as flat membranes, spheres, or donuts. Theorists say that our universe was created when two membrane shaped universes collided in the 11th dimension and caused the big bang in our universe. They also theorize that the membranes had fluctuations in there surfaces that caused the differences in texture we see in the microwave background radiation, which ultimately led to the formation of the first galaxies.

2007-11-23 12:51:27 · answer #7 · answered by straightshooter 5 · 0 0

The Big bang was a desperate attempt to save the theory of gravitação.Como to explain that the universe is if expanding, if the gravitational law is a contrary force?

2007-11-23 10:26:17 · answer #8 · answered by Rossetto 4 · 0 0

For a Newtonian mechanics physicist, it is hard to understand the Big Bang theory.
But ironically, this idea of Big Bang theory came from the mind of a religious person, a priest.
It is the birth of elementary particles.

2007-11-23 14:28:40 · answer #9 · answered by chanljkk 7 · 0 0

The Bible says that there was a Big Bang.

The matter was without form and void and darkness was upon the face of the deep (singularity) and God said "Let there be light" (big bang)

2007-11-23 10:19:40 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

fedest.com, questions and answers