Are writers shooting themselves in the foot with with their union mentality?

Question

If it were me, I would nogotiate my own contracts based on the caliber of my script or vision, not on what every other writer gets. Union metality limits, it doesn't give the opportunity to negotiate. I think that this strike would not have ever happened if writers took it upon themselves and perhaps agents to negotiate on a per project basis. By striking universal rules for pay and benifits they are only limiting their total potential. What are they going to do in another 10 ro 20 years when their compensation, it seems, no longer meets their needs? Srtike again? The asked for what they are getting now with the last strike. I'll ask again, isn't better to depend on your own negotiation skills or that of an agent?

Answer 1

In my opinion Hollywood writers are vastly underpaid for their contributions to TV and movie programing. However, it is not still not possible for the majority of the writers to negotiate contracts on their own that are as good or better than those the union negotiates. If they could the union would dissolve and there would be absolutely no support for a strike.

Answer 2

Actually Individuals in the WGA are completely free to negotiate their own contracts- the Basic Agreement is just a bottom line contract for the little guys who would otherwise have no leverage in a negotiation. Collective Bargaining in no way limits a member's ability to negotiate a better deal for them selves, it just raises the standard for those who can't.

Answer 3

The employers would simply point to the standard contract, and deny you anything extra you are asking for. It's not like it is hard to find writers. You would most likely not find any work if you went around asking for more then the accepted norm.

To me, many companies continually update their contracts to be fair. But sometimes they decide to not update their contracts and want to be unfair. That is when they strike. There have been many contracts over the years where the writers didn't strike, because they were treated fairly.

Answer 4

The way in whcih media is consumed is changing. Movies, Tv and other meda are now widely available online for purchase or screening or in box sets.

The writers former contract did not take into account the variable changes in the way in which the product they contributed to was consumed.

The writers are asking for a small amount of revenue from the sale of a product which they hold the rights to. It does not seem unreasonable.

Answer 5

How approximately we do away with public financing of public broadcasting and that they might call it that in the event that they need. many people do help them, they get fairly some listener help. it relatively is unlike they are going to might desire to circulate under, they might do exactly one greater fundraiser a 365 days or something. Or they might circulate cable or pay-consistent with-view or something. people who choose that's going to assist it. i think of Democrats are capturing themselves in the foot by making use of making a huge bushy deal out of union participants no longer getting a pay strengthen and having to kick in slightly for his or her reward. The united states is hurting and joblessness is severe. additionally, that's no longer purely Republicans tightening the belt. The governor of Colorado isn't a Republican and he's doing it too. we are extremely joyful. He says, "we are actually not elevating taxes to assist public pay will strengthen in this financial device." That coming from a Democrat, so cry on your beer.

Answer 6

Unions tend to be funding their own politics rather than members rights. It's really sad. I know I negotiated my pay in my jobs, & am willing to back up my work.
(I am not a writer I just play one on YA!!)

Answer 7

Right? Why on earth would you want someone else negotiating your pay.

Answer 8

i hope so!! they write second rate ripoff crap anyway...............