could germany have defeated france in ww2 if they had to cross the maginot line?

Question

oh please david s i bet you received an F in world history

Answer 1

Maybe not.
It was a continuous line of defences from the Swiss to the Belgian borders.
It consisted of deep bunkers and fortressses which were proof against all munitions available at that time with underground communications between each one and sleeping quarters, munition stores, canteens and even hospitals all underground,.
The armament consisted of heavy artillery and machine guns all arranged to cover every inch of ground up to five miles away with barbed wire entanglements , moats and ditches which the attackers would have to cross before getting close to the defenders.

Answer 2

Nope. If the Germans attacked the Maginot line they would've seen a near repeat of the First World War. A German Commander wanted this attack but another one ( look at the wiki article) decided to strike across France aiming for the Channel to cut off the British. In a series of repeated lightning strikes with Combined arms tank and infantry crews (not to mention the thousands of horses that pulled German troops) the Germans blitzkrieg the French least where they expected. They were in Paris in a month

Answer 3

The maginot line was nearly impenetrable a frontal assault would have been basically suicidal so the Germans would have needed to engage in an artillery duel which could have resulted in the English and French better prepping a counter offensive.

Answer 4

Counterfactual history, I love it. The Germans, simply, could not have crossed the Maginot Line, it wouldve likely culminated in yet another trench war, with very little progress. The fact that the French didn't prepare themselves for being flanked gave Hitler a pathetically easy alternative, through Belgium.

Answer 5

exciting question. My opinion is that, even though they might have failed the 1st time, ultimately they might have had the protection stress means to overwhelm France, the Maginot line would have been no actual impediment. I base this view on the weapons advancements going on in Germany at that element, in a pair of years or maybe much less because of the fact they weren't combating a war, they might have perfected ICBM's (V2) Jet fighter planes would be mass produced, they might have had Hydrogen bombs, and probable nuclear ones in some unspecified time interior the destiny, and that they might have long variety bombers that would attain us of a. I regularly think of if Hitler had waited for those advancements to be perfected the worldwide would be an somewhat distinctive place at present and we can possibly no longer have of venture of having a chair around the pool. although in answer on your question, maybe with out plenty fulfillment Hitler would have been much less possibly to have been waiting to whip the persons into one among those frenzy along with his present of speech. nonetheless he would have desperate Russia could be the objective for Germany's enlargement rather and moved East with the full would of the Germany military. regardless of their significant forces the Russians would have been defeated.. and then... who's easily-known with? center East, Asia. by applying that element he would administration such extremely some supplies including mant Axis forces that defeating something of Europe would be extremely ordinary. My Take :-)

Answer 6

Probably, but at a very high cost, in terms of men and resources. Thus, in the long run, it would have resulted in an earlier defeat for Germany, as far as WWII is concerned.

Answer 7

I suspect they would have used similar tactics to those employed against Eben Emael to create a crossing and left the rest of the fortifications to be dealt with at a later date through siege.

Answer 8

Germany did actually cross Maginot line!!! i bet you received an A in world history!!!

Answer 9

Yes, but it would of been a military blunder by the Germans. Why go up against the strongest defense when you can go around it through Belgium.

Answer 10

Yeah i think yes...


Cheers