Which QB should I start this week?

Question

Peyton Manning vs. San Diego
or
Ben Roethlisberger vs. Cleveland

Cleveland has statistically the worst pass defense in the league and Big Ben's been lighting it up lately, but there's just something about benching Peyton Manning that I can't get past. I need some outside opinions. Thanks.

Answer 1

I believe it wa week one or two that ben roethlisbergr burned the brows and blew them out and peyton vs san diego i dont like the matchup. Start big ben you have nothing to lose.

Answer 2

You can't go wrong with Peyton or Brady. Rule number 1. You should never sit either one of those two. Also, the chargers have the 25th best D in the league. Ben might be banged up as a result the Steelers might run the ball a lot. Good Luck!

Answer 3

I don't think you can lose in this situation. Both will have good days. After last week's loss the Colts will be psyched. And Big Ben hardly worked up a sweat in the second half of the Ravens game (he looked deadly in the first half).
When you have to make a tough choice always take the guy who is playing the worst D. I find this works best.

Answer 4

Ben got banged up against the Ravens, which must be factored in. You can't bench Manning...this is not the San Diego team of a year ago...far from it, especially on defense.

Answer 5

I agree with you I would bench roethlisberger. Tom brady's had a good season and Peytons only afew points behind him.
Good luck hope you win.

Answer 6

peyton
this is a big game, even against NE peyton still did well. so start peyton no doubt about it

Answer 7

Peyton Manning, even though I think he's overrated.

Answer 8

There shouldn't even be a question about it. No offense but the fact that you are even thinking of not strating manning is absurd.