Should Israelis leave the palestinian people in peace and give them back thier land?

Question

What do you think, should they just divide the country into two equal halves, or should the Israelis leave the palestinians in peace after 60 something years of baby killing, land stealing? Or do you find it normal what Israel is doing, and if so why.

Answer 1

they should definetly leave the palastinian lands. the israelis have commited every war crime imaginable against the palastinians, they have killed infants children women elders without any excuse and no one is stopping them. if you sit and read what they do to the palastinians i assure you that would not be able to rest an eye that day of the thought of the crimes commited.
i think that someone should stop them and put an end to this war and kick the israelis out of the lands they invaded and lived in without rights.
the americans and english were sick of the israelis because they were causing all sorts of trouble in their countries and so then decided to help them move to palastin to get rid of them and the problems they are causing. the israeli poeple have been causing problems many many years ago in the holy books. they are known that they killed the prophets and messengers of god and did all the sins imaginable.
i hope that this gives you an answer to your question.

Answer 2

Blame the orthodox Jews because of the fact they suspect all of Judah and Samaria belongs to them. what's the respond. Palestinians could have declared an self sufficient state lower back in 1948 yet have been excited by the British. Israel has the western powers backing them and not one of the Arab countries can try this. The PA knows Netanyahu wont end construction settlements, so why not address a diverse difficulty just to start negotiations? I dont be responsive to how lots would be left for a clean state after the history Plan is done. The Israelis might have moved out of Gaza Strip yet they somewhat have administration over stream. They patrol it, they bomb it, they bulldoze it, they blockade it and squeeze it. So, the Israelis might to boot nonetheless be there. a minimum of Hamas may be the place Fatah is and that they might have an accord between them. It sounds like israel tricked Hamas.

Answer 3

This question is a very difficult one, as it represents a problem with a long and bloody history. "The Holy Land" (specifically Jersulem) has changed hands more than any other region I can think of. This is due in part to the areas value as a port region but mostly because of religious significance to three of the world's major religons.

The problem of Jewish occupation becomes more difficult when you consider who created the state of Israel and why. First, it was after world war II that Brittain relinquished control of (then) Palestine in order to give Jews their historic homeland back after the diaspora. This was by and large an outcome that many Zionist Jews had championed for years and one that intensified after the events of the Holocaust were revealed. At the time, there was large public support for this in many western countries, and since the west ruled the world back then...

Next, consider the implications of dissolving the state of Israel, even to some partial degree. Should Canada and U.S.A relinquish control to the Native Americans? Should Scotland, North Ireland and Wales become free states? How about the Ainut Islands of Japan? There are many other examples of some state or power having control over the land another ethnic group claims by heritage and history.

This leads naturally into the philosophical nature of property rights, how can we decide who owns what, and by what rights?

In any event, I hope you understand the complexity of this problem and that the entire scope cannot likely be explored here. I would reccomend that you start reading the literature and discussing the issue with professors (if you have access to them.)

Last, I would simply like to point out that the terrorist actions of the Hebrews toward Palestinians did not occur in a vacuum. That has been a two-way street for ages. In days when terrorism meant little to Americans outside of the movie theater, both Jewish and Palestinian children understood the concept well.

Good luck in tackling one of the most engaging and important political issues of our time!

Answer 4

They should definately leave the Palestinians alone! I am not anti Jewish nor do I discriminate. I feel really strongly about what happened to them in World War II and I think a lot of people spite them just because they are successful and hard working people.

Now the reason why I don't think they should be figting the Palestinians over more teritory: I feel for the Palestinians - just ask yourselfs - how would you feel or react if someone just showed up one day and said half of your land is now someone elses and not yours - Deal with it!

Come on - wouldn't you fight against it. Why are Palestinians blamed for the promised land - and who can have any proof here that it was really promised to them by God!!!! It is just all ridicilous to me! It tears my heart in pieces when I see fighting in Jerusalem or Gaza, it is just ridicilous.

Take what you already got and make peace, that is how I feel. Why would you try to fight for more land when you already have one that is gorgeus. Tel Aviv is one of the most gorgeus cities out there, so leave poor Palestinians alone.

Peace!

Answer 5

Israel has done its best to leave the Palestinians alone, only on the condition that they stop their baby killing; but Palestine continues the attacks on defenseless civilians, and does it more whenever Israel shows a sign of making concessions.
The Palestinians have been offered 95% of what they say they want, but still they will not make peace.

Answer 6

Um YES. And those of you who call me anti semitic are the dumb ones. Semitic refers to a language group which refers to both Hebrew AND Arabic. ANNND there is a huge difference between Jews and the policies of the Israeli state. there are lots of jews against Israel look it up.
Watch Occupation 101
Read Palestine and the Arab Israeli Conflict: A History with documents by Charles D Smith.

I am a Middle Eastern History major and could spend hours lecturing on this topic and I have been in public debates over this issue.

The British empire did not own Israel... THE FRENCH DID. learn your history before you join the debate. The British had no right to give it in the first place!

Also for those of you who claim the Palestinians are terrorists... Look up IRGUN and the DEIR YASIN MASSACRE. I dont have the time to tell all here, but Do your homework and stop listening to FOX NEWS!
(BTW this is not to the asker... but to some of the answerers who dont know wat they are talking about!)

Oh and one more thing. Palestinians are the descendants of the Philistines. Ring a bell? Yah they were the ones in the Promised land before it was the Promised land. And to my accusatory little friend upstairs, I don't watch tv or listen to the radio. I don't maintain a 3.8 gpa, executive positions for the ahimsa student nonviolence center and the history honors society, two jobs, and a position on an award winning Model United Nations team by watching television. And the "adults" have done a famous job so far, haven't they? I'll just leave you "grown ups" to your complicated debate and get back to work on my thesis k? And anyone old enough to vote is free to join any political discussion they want and I passed that mark years ago.

Answer 7

The land is not theirs, a large Jewish population lived there since the beginning of documented history.
You are probable Muslim, brain washed by others, but know one thing.... the number of Israeli baby's MURDERED by Arabs is greater by far then the ones killed in war by Israelis, just as soon as Arabs stop fighting from within Arab populated areas the number of dead civilians will drop greatly, the name Palastinians was invented by Yasser Araffat, before that they were called refugees many had nothing to do with Israel.
The Arabs started the 47 war, THEY LOST
I will probobly not be rated by you as the best answer giver
MA'A'SALLAM O RACMAT ALLAH

Answer 8

Or all people can live there in peace. Both Palestinians and Israelis need to step up and stop acting so childish.

Yes, what Israel (the people who put it there) did was wrong...but a lot of innocent Jews, Christians, and Muslims live there...they just want peace...but many resort to violence for peace which is the wrong way to go as history has proven time and time again in the Middle-East.

Edit: President Hillary Clinton:
The Arabs hate us because of our dependence on OIL. We invade and kill for this stuff just so you can drive your car to work or the mall. It is not Israels fault (for the most part)...yes, they have done some stupid things in the past, but so have the Palestinians. Arabs flew planes into our buildings because we are free to vote, free to decide what religion we want, free to say anything we like...It is freedom they hate...not just our support of Israel.

EDIT AGAIN: President Hillary Clinton:
I agree with you that our support of Israel is somewhat (or mostly) why we are hated by terrorists...but does that mean we should be bullied into ending our support of the only democracy in the Middle-East? No. That would be stupid...at least for America. I really don't like what Israel has done. They have murdered so many innocent people it is not even funny...but it is not just Israel...both sides are at fault for this senseless violence. All people deserve to live there. If America left its nose out of every problem in this world, we wouldn't be in the rut we are in right now.

Answer 9

First of all, Prez Hillary Billary doesn't know what she is saying, what an idiot along with the other people who are anti-semitic.

With you answering your own stupid question, you sound anti-semitic too. The Land of Israel belongs to the Jews and it was never to the Palestinians. There is no such thing as Palestinians, they are Arabs. I think the Arabs should leave the Jewish people alone. The radical Islamists are the ones bombing the Jewish communities and using their own people as human shields. There should never be a two-state living side by side and the reason for saying this is because you have these radicals still firing off rockets and plus they don't want peace with the Jewish people!! Some of you don't know what really is going on in Israel do you??

Jewish are not baby killers or land stealers. Bunch of bull you are speaking here. You are told a bunch of lies regarding "Palestinian land". I think the radical Islamisists are the ones doing the killing. Now you have them wanting to invade the West Bank?? They are trying to steal Jewish land given to them by G-d Himself!

Conclusion: I found it right for what Israel is doing by defending themselves and defending THEIR land from terrorists. I found it right for Israel to protect Her people from Islamo-fascists who want to destroy them. Who ever is against G-d, will be defeated, period!!

By the way, please do some History background regarding Israel. You may learn something. Or, you can read the book called, "Big Lies"

"I WILL BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU AND WHOEVER CURSES YOU I WILL CURSE" (Genesis 12:3)

Answer 10

I believe the palestinian's have been fighting for their land since the 1930's yes they should get it back, the whole thing is so stupid, someone has way too much horsepower over there.