will these football players make the hall of fame?

Question

Would they make it if they retired today or if they continue playing as they do? Why or Why not?

1. Randy Moss
2. Chad Johnson
3. Carson Palmer
4. Donovan Mcnabb
5. Marvin Harrison
6. Reggie Wayne
7. Ronde Barber
8. Tiki Barber (already retired)
9. Shaun Alexander
10. Ed Reed
11. Ray Lewis
12. Jeremiah Trotter
13. Jevon Kearse
14. Brian Dawkins
15. Matt Hasselbeck
16. Ben Roethlisberger

i forgot. what do you think of brian westbrook and drew brees?

Answer 1

1. Randy Moss - yes, the most talented WR ever...better than rice
2. Chad Johnson - yes, but doesnt deserve it, all hype
3. Carson Palmer - if he continues to play at this level for 8 more years yes
4. Donovan Mcnabb - no, the guy is a joke and a choke artist
5. Marvin Harrison - yes
6. Reggie Wayne - same as palmer
7. Ronde Barber - yes
8. Tiki Barber (already retired) - nope, guy fumbled way too much, and didnt play at a high level for long enough
9. Shaun Alexander - depends on how he bounces back, if he can recovery from injury then yes, but it looks like not
10. Ed Reed - yes, the best safety in the NFL for the past 5 years
11. Ray Lewis - yes, one of the most feared defenders ever, and a superbowl MVP
12. Jeremiah Trotter - ha, no
13. Jevon Kearse - nope, he fizzled out over the past 4 years, and hasnt managed to stay healthy or productive to make it
14. Brian Dawkins - no
15. Matt Hasselbeck - no
16. Ben Roethlisberger - yes

the hall of fame is selective and bias. there are many players that are better than the ones mentioned above that are neglected every year.

Answer 2

1. Randy Moss
Yes
2. Chad Johnson
No
3. Carson Palmer
No, but he is young enough that this could change if he improves
4. Donovan Mcnabb
A soft no.
5. Marvin Harrison
Yes
6. Reggie Wayne
Probably not
7. Ronde Barber
No
8. Tiki Barber (already retired)
No, not if the voters vote honestly. But he might get in because he played in a big market and handled the press well.
9. Shaun Alexander
Needs to turn things around next year, if not, no.
10. Ed Reed
No.
11. Ray Lewis
On talent, yes. Character? Let's just say being involved in a murder will lose him some votes. I'll say no.
12. Jeremiah Trotter
No
13. Jevon Kearse
No
14. Brian Dawkins
No
15. Matt Hasselbeck
No
16. Ben Roethlisberger
Possiblity. Another title or an MVP season would clinch it.

Answer 3

1. Randy Moss not now maybe after.
2. Chad Johnson same as Moss
3. Carson Palmer No and it doesn't look like he will
4. Donovan Mcnabb No no ring
5. Marvin Harrison Yes 1 ring many records
6. Reggie Wayne no he's just a complimentary player.
7. Ronde Barber No
8. Tiki Barber (already retired) No
9. Shaun Alexander No
10. Ed Reed He might need 1 more ring.
11. Ray Lewis Yes too well known not to.
12. Jeremiah Trotter No
13. Jevon Kearse No
14. Brian Dawkins Maybe on another team
15. Matt Hasselbeck No
16. Ben Roethlisberger Needs more rings

Answer 4

1. Randy Moss - Yes
2. Chad Johnson - Needs a SB win
3. Carson Palmer - No
4. Donovan Mcnabb - Needs a SB win
5. Marvin Harrison - Yes
6. Reggie Wayne - No
7. Ronde Barber - No
8. Tiki Barber (already retired) - No
9. Shaun Alexander - No
10. Ed Reed - No
11. Ray Lewis - Yes
12. Jeremiah Trotter - No
13. Jevon Kearse - No
14. Brian Dawkins - No
15. Matt Hasselbeck - No
16. Ben Roethlisberger - Needs at least one more SB win
17. Brian Westbrook - No
18. Drew Brees - Needs a SB win

Answer 5

In my opinion:

1. Randy Moss-Yes
2. Chad Johnson-No
3. Carson Palmer-Yes
4. Donovan Mcnabb-No
5. Marvin Harrison-Yes
6. Reggie Wayne-No
7. Ronde Barber-No
8. Tiki Barber (already retired)-No
9. Shaun Alexander-No
10. Ed Reed-Yes
11. Ray Lewis-Yes
12. Jeremiah Trotter-No
13. Jevon Kearse-Yes
14. Brian Dawkins-Yes
15. Matt Hasselbeck-No
16. Ben Roethlisberger-Yes

a super bowl ring goes a long way.

Answer 6

1. Randy Moss - Yes
2. Chad Johnson - not today, perhaps if he keeps playing well
3. Carson Palmer - No
4. Donovan Mcnabb - No
5. Marvin Harrison - Yes
6. Reggie Wayne - not today, perhaps if he keeps playing well
7. Ronde Barber - No
8. Tiki Barber (already retired) - No
9. Shaun Alexander - No
10. Ed Reed - not today, perhaps if he keeps playing well
11. Ray Lewis - Yes
12. Jeremiah Trotter - No
13. Jevon Kearse- No
14. Brian Dawkins - No
15. Matt Hasselbeck - No
16. Ben Roethlisberger - not today, perhaps if he keeps playing well
17. Brian Westbrook - not today, perhaps if he keeps playing well
18. Drew Brees - No

Answer 7

1. Randy Moss-YES
2. Chad Johnson-YES
3. Carson Palmer-NO
4. Donovan Mcnabb-YES
5. Marvin Harrison-YES
6. Reggie Wayne-NO
7. Ronde Barber-NO
8. Tiki Barber (already retired)-YES (barely and if he stops rattin on people.)
9. Shaun Alexander-NO
10. Ed Reed-YES
11. Ray Lewis-YES
12. Jeremiah Trotter-YES
13. Jevon Kearse-NO
14. Brian Dawkins-NO
15. Matt Hasselbeck-NO
16. Ben Roethlisberger-YES

Answer 8

Moss-Yes; top 5 WR in the last 10 years
Johnson-no; what has he ever really dont but run his mouth
Palmer-not right now maybe one day but i dont think so
McNadd-If he can put to gether a good 2nd hafe of a Carrier then yes.
Harrison-yes; he is the closet thing we have today to Rice
Wayne-yes; If he can continues to play the way he dose
Barber-yes; He has had a good Carrier, he is OK as a shutdown CB but one of the Biggest hitting CB we have had for a long time
T.Barbed-No;again what has he done?
Alexander-no; /\ /\ /\ /\ /\ /\ /\ /\ /\ /\ /\
Reed-yes; great player needs to play for a few more years
Lewis-yes; Cant stand his mouth but maybe the best LB in the last 10 years
Trotter-I dont know enough about him to say
Kearse- really to early to say maybe one day
Dawkins-no; good player not great(just what i think)
Hasseleck-no; The only QBs playing right now the are going to the HoF are Farve, Manning and Brady
Roethlisberger-not yet; way to early to tell only his 3rd year give him time

Answer 9

Moss - Yes
Johnson - No
Palmer - No
McNabb - No
Harrison - Yes
Wayne - No
Ronde Barber - No
Tiki Barber - No
Alexander - No
Reed - Yes
Lewis - No
Trotter - No
Kearse - No
Dawkins - Yes
Hasselbeck - No
Roethlisberger - No

Answer 10

1. No.
2. Yes. (He even wore the jacket that said so)
3. Too early to tell. So far, so good.
4. Yes.
5. Yes.
6. No.
7. No.
8. No.
9. Yes.
10. Yes.
11. Yes.
12. No.
13. No.
14. Yes.
15. No.
16. Yes.

Westbrook won't, Brees will.