Would you trade Derrick Anderson for Steve Smith or Torry Holt?

Question

I also have Manning as a quarterback. Thanks for all of the responses.

Answer 1

Derrick Anderson is extremely hot right now. Steve Smith and Torry Holt are having sub-par years mainly because of their QB's issues with there respective teams. No way do you make a trade for these two unless your starting QB is Tom Brady, P.Manning or Carlson Palmer.. Get what I'm saying??? Your starter has to be a STUD!!!

Answer 2

Assuming that you meant to say that you have Peyton Manning at QB I would trade Derek Anderson for Torry Holt but not Steve Smith. Without Delhomme at the helm Smith is having a sub-par year.

I can see Holt turning things up with Bulger as his QB and Steven Jackson returning to form.

Good luck!

Answer 3

First I even have Steve Smith in my league and that i would not settle for this commerce if it became presented to me. You look at this and steve smith gets thrown the ball approximately 13 circumstances a game if not extra, and he's the extra useful receiver for yards after the catch and has extra useful strikes i think of then holt....you won't be able to look finally weeks overall performance by myself...Steve smith has been getting double lined for the previous 3 years and nevertheless manages a hundred and fifty backyard video games, torry holt is a lot an analogous yet final week he performed a seattle def. it rather is extremely susceptible against the bypass def. on an analogous time as carolina performed a stable team in balt. and steve smith nevertheless pulled off those numbers....i additionally sense that delhomme has the extra useful arm and accuracy over bulger

Answer 4

Only if Anderson is your #2 QB.

Answer 5

i wouldnt tradde for smith because is isnt playin good as of late but i would trade for holt

Answer 6

If he is your #1 QB and your backup is average then no but if not then yes or are you the guy with the receivers? if you are then do it if you need a QB

Answer 7

Check the stats....DA is putting together weeks that are better than those two receivers combined. I would not make the deal for either receiver.

Answer 8

it depends on who youre other qb's are. if yourw pretty much set there, then go with steve smith.

if you are having trouble at qb. dont trade him