Do OE Replacement Parts Measure Up?

Question

Original equipment replacement parts is sold over the counter of vehicle dealers and they say they are the same or better than originals. My experience says otherwise. My car muffler lasted nine years. I bought an OE replacement at the dealer for a high price and it lasted less than three years. What do you think?

Answer 1

I'm somewhat confused by your statement. Most OE parts purchased at your dealer are made by sub-contractors to your car manufacturer's specifications. We never know who really makes these parts because the suppliers are always changing. Your car company places bids out to suppliers and unfortunately the lowest bid wins.

We are supposed to believe OE stuff is the best but I'm with you. Take Ford for instance. Tie-rod ends go bad in a very short time because they are sealed units. If you're smart you replace with Moog or TRW fittings with grease fittings that will last forever. I'd like to place my 13 sized shoe in Ford's back side because they cut corners and put cheap inner and outer tie-rod ends on their cars.

You had faith that your replacement exhaust OEM system would live as long as the original. Well, it seams that some low life bidder made your pipes and muffler. Personally I've always had good luck with Walker stuff as the hangers are correct and the pipes always fit. Our customers have been happy with the overall quality and life of their products.

Answer 2

OEM parts are the same as the originals. These are the parts that your car was built with. OEM means Original Equipment Manufacturer, not always ford, dodge, chevy, etc... If Moog makes parts sold to Toyota for a car line, then sell that part to NAPA to sell It is OEM. Maybe you had some other problems that cut the life down on your muffler. Or, there could have been a change in the materials that the part was made of. One way or the other, just get parts you trust. Either better price, or better quality, it's up to the consumer (you).