Who got the better end of the Blue Jays-Padres trade?

Question

The trade that sent Fred McGriff and Tony Fernandez to San Diego for Joe Carter and Roberto Alomar.

Answer 1

From a Jays' fan point-of-view, that was the best trade in the history of our franchise. It was tough to give up McGriff, but in return we got the best second basemen of the decade. Alomar was an absolute stud during his time in Toronto, and he was probably our most valuable player on both offense and defense during those glory years.

Joe Carter provided some power for us, but McGriff is undoubtedly the better of those two players. His OBP was consistently way higher than what Joe did, and he was a relatively smooth fielder. Tony Fernandez did okay after the trade, but I really feel like his best work had already been done by the time the deal was made.

I can't say it was horribly lopsided talent-wise, but I believe the Jays got the better of the deal because it was the biggest thing that pushed them over that hump. Crime Dog continued to put up big numbers, but Alomar was easily the most outstanding player in that group.

Answer 2

As I have memories of Joe Carter's homer in the Series... the Jays.

Answer 3

Blue Jays considering they won the world series twice.

Answer 4

Jays

Answer 5

AL East pink Sox AL correct White Sox AL West Rangers AL Wild Card Yankees NL East Phillies NL correct Cardinals NL West Giants NL Wild Card Braves Reasoning pink Sox: all round stacked club, with far more suitable suitable pitching than the Yankees. Crawford will commence to warmth up and the crew with take off. White Sox: in simple terms I dont imagine the Indians will carry on and the White Sox and Tigers are the in simple terms different ideas for my area. good crew, yet receives overwhelmed contained in the playoffs Rangers: susceptible branch, sturdy crew. Cruz and Hamilton are again, assume the AL West to be a laugher Yankees: they're sturdy sufficient to win the different branch although the East. no longer as sturdy as they'd seem, as they have not started to have any significant injuries and are driving on the fat again of Colon, which I dont see taking position all year lengthy Phillies. Halladay, Oswalt, Hamels, Lee. sufficient stated Cardinals. yet another susceptible branch., they're on good now inspite of a countless injuries and an uncharacteristically mediocre Albert Pujols. Giants. They nevertheless have the pitching paintings force, yet dropping Posey hurts. Will probable %. up a catcher in the previous the ruin. Huff and Ross are heating up so the offense isnt searching as undesirable because it may be Braves: a spectacular crew with sturdy pitching and larger suitable hitting than very last year. might want to overtake the Marlins by the ruin and in no way seem again NL MVP Ryan Braun AL MVP Adrian Gonzalez NL CY youthful Josh Johnson AL Cy youthful Jared Weaver AL Rookie Of The year Michael Pineda NL Rookie Of The year Darwin Barney Midseason strikes Giants get Ivan Rodriguez Jose Reyes and/or David Wright get moved Barry Zito receives struck by lightning (I want) Padres deal Heath Bell to Cardinals, as they go with a closer and the Padres will be out of it by July 31 Offseason Pujols to Cubs for 8 year/225 million Fielder to Yankees 7 year 184 million (will play DH) Reyes signs and symptoms with Giants 5 years 70 million Berkman continues to be with the playing cards for 2 years 25 million Rivera and Posada retire, forcing the Yankees to commerce for Soria and empty out the farm equipment Mark DeRosa compelled to retire using injuries Tom from MySpace creates a fb

Answer 6

Obviously the Jays. I mean they won the world series with them, right??

Answer 7

Wow.............that rhymes.

BLUE JAYS----------PADRES