will you divorce a women who won't give you a child ?

Question

I think one should not divorce a women who can't give her a child but one must divorce a women who won't give a child.

thanks for so many answers.
i am a 17 year old girl and just want to know public openion.

Answer 1

No but i can't legally marry a woman and the last time i checked two women can not make a baby together so it's a big no.

Answer 2

The woman has a choice, and the woman has every right to change her mind (even if it was discussed prior to marriage and she wanted a child then). So I don't see how it's lying. I understand both sides. Maybe she feels she wouldn't be a good parent and making a smart choice, rather than giving the child a poor quality or horrible life. I mean I could see where the divorce plays in but not everone is meant to be a parent. Not all marriages are based on having children. And not all people/couples can have children.

Answer 3

once you mixture the families, the two husband and spouse (in a appropriate international) could desire to settle for one yet another, and one yet another's infants. the youngsters could desire to be dealt with the two via the two factors, and it won't count who has funds, and who does not. You the two went into this marriage, (i'm hoping) understanding what one yet another's financial business enterprise money owed appear like, and what difficulty you have been the two in. If the husband isn't treating the youngsters appropriate, then i might desire the spouse might call him on it, and additionally you the two might artwork on it. If the husband is doing as you're saying he's, then it is not a kosher relationship, and the two marriage counseling is so as, or a divorce could desire to be. the youngsters could desire to consistently come first, not final, and by no skill dealt with as "stepchildren". it is financial abuse and a skill/administration difficulty on his area, if it is truly going on. get out NOW! and if the ex-husband is "undesirable", properly, sorry, yet they're his infants, and can be his precedence, although I truly have a suspicion it is why he's the "ex"... **and to the guy who says 'divorce is poison' could desire to understand there's a want for divorce from abusive spouses, and is not for vulnerable people who wanna run away. I take offense to that, and till you stroll in somebody else's shoes who's been via it, please shop your comments to your self! that's an internet site to help people, not decide them!

Answer 4

I think if it was agreed that you would have children before you married then you enter into that contract believing that to be the case. If one person changes their mind then that is a breach of the contract and shouldn't be tolerated unless there are very good reasons e.g. finding out you have a serious genetic disorder. However, if one person then finds they cannot provide that child, then its a matter of consideration within that marriage. Its not grounds for divorce but it could well be very sad.

Answer 5

Well, was this something that was discussed prior to the wedding, or was this something that you assumed she would do? Because that is going to really dictate the answer to the question is. If you assumed that she wanted children you can't expect her to live up to your assumptions. But if you discussed this and agreed on this prior to marriage, find out what changed her mind. I mean lets get under the surface and try to find out what the real problem is before we divorce. But ultimatley, its the womans body, but if her refusing to carry a child is a deal breaker for you than, I suggest that you remember your needs are just as equal as hers. And if there is no compromise, it doesn't mean you should have to compromise your needs!

Answer 6

I've had this very conversation with some friends and what I came up with is this,,,,These are things that should come up before marriage. You should talk about that becasue that's gonna be the 1st question I ask before I say I DO. If she can't bear children that's totally different. But if she is able and not willing then odds are I can't marry her. In your case it's too late for all that so explore other options like adoption.

Answer 7

well if the women told him that she was interested in having children before they got married then she lied to him and that is worth leaving over.cause he thought he was marrying and starting a family and all.
but is she planning on having some later then thats okay she wants to make sure it is the right time and mom always know best.
maybe she wants to wait to have enough money and plan ahead which makes alot of sense. but if she don't want one at all and you do then ya you have a problem ...talk it over and if you can't come to an agreement then move on.

Answer 8

No, I happen to be a woman who is not able to have children and my ex-husband divorced me. he said it had nothing to do with the fact that I couldn't have children but, I found out after the fact that he was cheating on me & the girl got prenant. I guess I got the last laugh on him as she has divorced him & now he pays her child support.

Answer 9

It depends on if you two discussed it before you got married. I mean if it is that important to the person who wants kids that they would get divorced from the person who does not, then they should have made sure before they got married that they were on the same page. Basic rule to not getting divorced is to discuss all the important big things before one gets married.

Answer 10

You must find out why she wont have a child. There are many reasons most could be fear.. A good long talk about this would help to find out what it might be and see if can be resolved before going to the extreme.