who is the thrid best quarterback in the NFL?

Question

It's obvious that Romo and Manning are the class of nfl quarterbacks. Romo might have become better than Manning this year, especially after having a couple monster games. Manning while he only had one throwing touchdown is clearly also talented. But after these two it seems the talent level clearly seems to drop. Who is the third best? Brady is good but so overrated its ridiculous and anyone who watch his last game knows that he just throws the ball up and he is not all that accurrate. VY is can run, and Palmer is not all there this year.

Answer 1

The best are obviously Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. After that I'll say Drew Brees, Brett Favre, Carson Palmer, and Tony Romo. Brady has been to how many superbowls even with average receivers and you say he's overrated? Well just what justifies that? Also the numbers do not lie or the results sir. When Mr Romo plays in his first superbowl then we will discuss it. He's good but not as good as those I've mentioned as you are clearly biased in your opinion. Try being more objective. By the way, I'm a Falcons fan unfortunately.

Thumbs down huh because ypu disagree? Real classy!!!!!

Answer 2

Why people keep saying Brady is nothing special, It's all his receivers, is beyond me and totally rediculous. Before this season he had no help on the receiving end and he made everybody better. And now just cause his receiving core is making him look good makes him less of a QB, I DON'T THINK SO. The guy is awesome. Look at Dante Culpepper once Randy Moss was taken away from him he was nothing. Brady was doing it long before Randy Moss got there. Moss just complements him, very well. There has never been a better QB than Tom Brady. Although I'd put Peyton Manning right there with him, But Peyton's always had great receivers to throw to. I would have to say that Romo has been impressive thus far, and I think Jeff Garcia is a very underrated QB and playing with a mediocre group on the Offensive line with no running attack. And one other honorable mention is a healthy Donovan McNabb. He has nobody to throw to this year except Westbrook.

Answer 3

Romo is in now way the top QB in league. He has the tools to possibly be considered one day. But the top QB in the league should never throw 5 INTs in a game. IN a few years Romo will be experienced and Manning and Brady will be old and then we can talk about Romo as the top QB.

1-Peyton Manning
1a-Tom Brady
3-Carson Palmer

4-maybe Romo

Answer 4

I don't know what you're thinking but Brady is a much better QB than Romo would ever hope to be. I think that the third best QB in the league is Donovan McNabb when healthy. He does not have the right tools this year to be good and he is still somewhat injured. That being said, I think that the third best QB this year is Bret Farve. He has been playing great all year and teams know that the Packers are going to pass the ball more times than they run.

Answer 5

Brady...overrated? How so? The guy has been so consistent in his career and if you look at who he throws to, how is that any different from who Romo, Manning, and Palmer throw to?

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady (I have to put him here until he breaks all the records)
3. Carson Palmer
4. Drew Brees
5. Marc Bulger (When healthy)
6. Tony Romo (Although I'd like to see him raise his completion percent to above 60%)

Answer 6

Tony Romo.

Tom Brady has three rings and Randy Moss. Peyton Manning has one ring, a zillion yards career passing and a whole legion of solid receivers each year.

Tony Romo, though he has a whole lot of promise, has about 16 career starts, one big playoff debacle and a recent game where he tossed 5 INTs. Romo is a solid #3 despite not being as physically gifted as Carson Palmer.

Answer 7

The record speaks for itself, ROMO! He's been doing his thing since he took over the healm of the Cowboys. Favre is definitely running a close 4th. Some mentioned Eli but as a New York native I've gotten to see the Giants game and what Barber said about his leadership ability does have some credibility to it.

Answer 8

Carson Palmer is the third best quarterback in the NFL. He's better then Brett Favre, Tony Romo, Ben Rothlisberger, Matt Hasselbeck, & Phillip Rivers.

Answer 9

this is the first year that brady has had good recievers, brady is definately the best, then manning palmer and garcia. Romo still has a long way to go to be considered one of the best in the NFL.

Answer 10

Romo=Danny White .

Best 2 are Brady and Manning after that its whoever is playing the Bengals.