shy should the palestinians and other arabs pay for the sins against the jews that the arabs never committed?

Question

by ashley robinson Member since:
July 15, 2007
Total points:
1349 (Level 3) the palestinians should never compromise with israel. israel has violated 71 UN resolutions. saddam only violated 17. israel is a joke. been to lebanon twice. i have seen the truth. anybody who supports israeli terrorism will burn in hell right next to the suicide bombers that have attacked israel. two wrongs never make a right. look around you. the jews control america. cnn, fox, abc, cbs, nbc, msnbc; every ceo of those news agencies are jews. you have to always consider the source when you get your news. have you ever wondered why it is that we can't get other countries' news.

arabs had nothing to do with jewish destruction in 132 AD, nor did they have anything to do with nazi germany during world war II. why should the palestinians and other arab countries just pack up their stuff and do as the jews wish. the jews are no more special than anyone else. obviously their promise of the holy land

obviously their promise of the holy lands were broken when they denied their messiah. how do i know their promise was broken you wonder? they were killed, raped, sold in slavery and forced into exile by the roman empire. nowhere did the arabs do anything to the jews. i root like hell against the zionist pigs. if they had not been terrorizing arabs for the last 60 years, i would feel differently.

the jews can in no way think that after being gone for almost 1800 years just walk in and reclaim land they believe was promised to them by a god they turned their backs on and just assume the arabs should do whatever they wish. this land is the palestinians land. they had nothing at all to do with anything that has been pushed on the jews throughout history.

what is a shame is how the arabs allowed the jews and christians to remain jews and christians even after the jewish exile in 132 AD. everyone says that muslims want to convert the whole world or kill them. this is a lie.

how else can you explain the jews and christians who lived their for 1800 years while the jews fled their "promised" land.

if god was on their side, how is it they were forced to leave their "promised" land for 1800 years? i mean if they were so special and holy, how could they not trust in their god? because their religion is a lie. and now the arabs have to pay for the sins they never committed.

hey ninja, i never said the jews committed any sins. where did you get that from. and the palestinians never killed the jews until the jews imprisoned the palestinians. the palestinians have a right to fight back. i am against the killing of all innocents. but this includes ALL innocents. not one palestinian had a damn thing to do with the holocaust or the jewish exile done to them by the romans.

Un pc, i guess you don't count their 1800 exile done to them by the roman empire. yeah, lets not let facts get in the way of the truth.

Answer 1

I don't think Israel should exist, but I don't really care enough to do anything about it, you cant change the past.

Answer 2

At this point the vast majority of jewish Israelis were born and raised there, as were many of their parents, so the Israelis legitimately belong there now. The question now is how can Israeli Jews and Palestinians (the biblical Philistines) live in peace? If Israel annexes Gaza and the West Bank, millions more Palestinians would be able to vote, not to mention that millions of Palestinians living in Jordan, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon would likely return to give the Palestinian Israelis a majority. This is the solution supported by Iran and many other countries.
Most Jews consider this to be unacceptable, since they'd become a minority in their own country, though this is currently the case for the Palestinians.
Most Jews and the U.S. support a two state solution. This seems difficult, however, since the Palestinians would need to cross through Israel to travel from Gaza to the West Bank. Also, Zionist extremists are building illegal towns in the West Bank, trying to put the Israeli govt. in a very awkward position. Zionists want to annex all Palestinian land and exile all Palestinians. Since the U.S. and Israeli govts. are ignoring the Zionist expansion into the West Bank, it is self evident that both regimes support the Zionist "ultimate solution" for all practical intents and purposes.
What I find fascinating is that Al Qaeda doesn't attack Israel or the Illegal settlements there. This proves that Al Qaeda only uses abuse of the Palestinians as an excuse for causing Mid East turmoil in an attempt to orchestrate a takeover of at least one Arab country to begin an extremist Islamic expansion. It has nothing to do with Israel and the U.S. really.

Answer 3

There is no doubt that the Jewish people have undergone years of prejudice and cruelty as they wandered the earth. The Holocaust took place in Germany before and during WW!!, but the pograms and brutality continued long before that. One really can't blame them, as a people, for fighting back, becoming more aggressive, more defensive.

On the other hand, the Palestinean people have been unfairly treated, driven from homes they were born in, made to endure life in horrible ghettos, fighting back with the only weapons they had, the lives of those willing to give up their lives to become martyrs. Incomprehensible to us, but admirable and understanding to them.

No, Arabs should not pay for the sins against the Jews. No one should pay for sins or crimes committed in history, and the cruelty against Jews was not primarily Arab. If this were the case, Americans would suffer for crimes committed against Indians, Mexicans, and others.

I am hoping...praying...for a Palestinean state, a country where these people can have the pride and purpose they deserve. If Arab and Jew could live as neighbors at peace, what an accomplishment that would be! But they aren't going to do it with acts of aggression against each other, or in leaving massive damage as in Lebanon. And they aren't going to do it with the United States favoring and funding Jews, while ignoring the plight of the Arabs.

Answer 4

This is a tricky one to answer. I agree that the Palestinians have been unfairly treated. When Israel was made a state, it meant that land had to be taken from other countries to give it to the Jews. But, chasing them out of Israel and taking over their homes and business was not right. Palestinians then became refugees that other countries did not want to support. I don't know the answer, but I can't blame them for being angry about how they have been treated, and because we have supported Israel with arms and financially, it's the main reason the Arab nations hate us and want revenge.

Answer 5

"The land formerly known as Palestine."

The region formerly known as Palestine was formerly known as Israel and only renamed to Palestine by the romans in order to offend the Jews who lived there

Maybe you have never read a history book but the Jews have been continuously living there for over three thousand years. Oh, and by the time Israel was established in 1948, the Jews **already** owned 12.5% of the land, purchased from Turkish farmers.

How long have Arabs or Muslims been living there? Nowhere near as long. Half of jewish history had already happened there by the time Mohammed even spoke his first words.

Answer 6

This is all very well, but it is time that Arabs start to recognize that Israel is going nowhere. It is time for them to forget about driving Israel into the sea, to be realistic and starting figuring out how to arrange the middle east to their advantage and start coming up with some proposals no how to co-exist with the state of Israel. As long as Arabs continue to flog this dead horse, the lives of Palestinians will be tragically on hold.

One would almost think there is some advantage to many Arab governments to allow this pot to boil for as long as possible. Palestinians, stop being the pawns of your Arab cousins, and start to think, and act, for yourselves.
-

Answer 7

Hey what's your solution? This was set up 50 years ago by the UN. Get over it and promote peace. No reason we can't have an Israeli state and Palestinian state living side by side.

Answer 8

Blowing up thousand of innocent women and children isnt a sin?


The arabs will get along with Israel at some point or they will fight until the whole region is dead.

Answer 9

I don't give a damn.

What I do know is that we should be making decisions based on our self-interst, not the interest of jews or arabs.

Answer 10

SIanbts realy lets look
oh there are sucde bobmbers insurgnts lan thivves maruders rapists kindnappers so wrong arabs must atone for thier sins against jew and chirtians

Answer 11

You're right. Two wrongs don't make a right. What do thousands of wrongs committed by both sides make?