Which graphic card is better MSI RX2600XT or the Geforce 8600 gts from any brand?

Question

I'm having a struggle between this two cards because they are mid-range cards plus it is dx10, dont really care much for dx9 even there are some cards better than the two. the msi has a better clock speed and memory spped, but the 8600 gts is somewhat better because i've seen charts of comparisons and the 8600 gts beat the rx2600xt, but yet the rx2600xt is faster or not?

You know what, which is is better. the MSI RX2600XT or the MSI NX8600gts..compare..please the 2600 cost 115 after mail in rebate the 8600gts cos 130 after mail in rebate,,dont know,,so choose which one is better. by the way both cards are in that price at newegg.

Answer 1

Generally, in games, 2600XT is faster when A-A and filtering are turned OFF, but gets beaten by 8600GTS when A-A and filtering are turned ON.
http://www.trustedreviews.com/graphics/review/2007/07/16/ATI-Radeon-HD-2600-XT-2600-Pro-and-2400-XT/p8
http://www.trustedreviews.com/graphics/review/2007/07/16/ATI-Radeon-HD-2600-XT-2600-Pro-and-2400-XT/p9
http://www.trustedreviews.com/graphics/review/2007/07/16/ATI-Radeon-HD-2600-XT-2600-Pro-and-2400-XT/p10

Answer 2

A 8600 GTS 512 for that value isn't an quite good deal. For around $20 (greater or much less) of which you will get plenty greater useful overall performance from a 256 ATI X1950XT. besides the certainty that it has much less reminiscence (which many times purely is clever in extremely severe resolutions), and not DX 10 (little or no pastime help), it is going to likely be greater useful in all different techniques. verify to learn in the adventure that your potential furnish can shelter it through fact it takes up a great form of potential and heat. in case you'll have DX 10, another ideas are the ATI HD 2600 XT or Nvidia Geforce 8600 GT (verify you %. the DDR3 variations). besides the certainty that they provide much less reminiscence, they seem to be a around $one hundred and furnish little or no overall performance lost. in case you're keen to pay somewhat greater, get the 8800 GTS (320 mb till at extremely severe resolutions). It expenses approximately $60 greater yet you will see a great improve in overall performance. lower back verify in the adventure that your laptop can help those video enjoying cards first.