Best NFL Quarterback of ALL time?

Question

1. Joe Montana

2. Steve Young

3. John Elway

4. Dan Marino

5. Brett Farve.

6. Peyton Manning

7. Troy Aikman

8. Tom Brady

9. Don't know

10. Don't know


The 49ers are the best franchise in sports history.

Answer 1

You are a NINERS fan CLEARLY.

1. John Elway
2. Brett Favre
3. Joe Montana
4. Dan Marino
5. Peyton Manning
6. Tom Brady
7. Johnny Unitas
8. Terry Bradshaw
9. Joe Namath
10. Roger Staubach

Honorable Mentions: Steve Young, Bob Griese, Fran Tarkenton, Warren Moon, Jim Kelly.

Answer 2

1.Joe Montana
2.John Elway
3.Brett Farve
4.Steve Young
5.Johnny Unitas
6.Jim Kelly
7.Peyton Manning
8.Tom Brady
9.Troy Aikman
10.Otto Graham
11.Bart Starr
12.Terry Bradshaw

Answer 3

Superbowls don't matter Stavi... Peyton Manning will always be better than Brady for now just cause you NE fans are used to whinnying and crying until you get everything handed to you it's not gonna work on the Best of all time list, Manning's stats kills Brady's, for the fact that Manning is more experienced and has been playing longer, same with the facts that Brady has more SB MVP's he's played in more how ever Brady won 2/3 that's 66.6% Manning has won 1/1 equaling to 100% if we judge QB's based on SB's then Marino wouldn't be there and Elway would not be there, Superbowl Championships are because the TEAM was great not just the QB. And if we judged them based on records then Montana and Young wouldn't be there. Personally I dont like these "of ALL time" lists because you can't compare someone like Peyton Manning to someone like Joe Montana, football has changed totally. The first NFL Most Passing TD's in a career was something like 60 and now its from 420 and still going. Sammy Baugh should be in that league even though he only has something 90 TD's in his career he is still a Hall of Famer and has revolutionized the QB position.

Answer 4

As of right now it should be: 1) Favre 2) Marino 3) Montana 4) Unitas 5) Elway 6) Young 7) Bradshaw 8) Aikman 9) Manning 10) Brady. Brady and Manning will move up this list substantially. I picked Favre because he owns all the records and because of his toughness, ability to make his teammates better, leadership, and longevity. The number of Championships won matters but it is one of many factors that need to be taken into consideration.

Answer 5

Brett Favre
Roger Staubach
John Unitas
John Elway
Joe Montana
Sammy Baugh
Otto Graham
Bob Waterfield

Answer 6

I'm going with the only 3 time MVP in NFL history. Brett Favre. When was the last time he had a go to guy not named Donald Driver? Who on any other team aside from the last year and 6 games wouldn't even be a number one guy.

Answer 7

I was in Las Vegas last year, and got to meet a number of NBA celebs. One in particular I remember was Dr J. He was standing right next to anther Hall of Famer, Clyde Drexler. Anyway, aside from being a little awestruck, I asked Dr J who he thought was the best NBA player ever, himself, Michael Jordan, or somebody else. Aside from not looking too happy with the question, both Dr J and Drexler thought it might be Bill Russell. Bill Russell?? Why? Simply put, Bill Russell's Boston Celtics won more championships than anybody else. A class act? They don't come any classier than Julius Erving. Anyway, if I were to relate that to football championships, Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw seem, to this point to be above all the rest. To the best of my knowledge, they have won more championships than anybody. I'm a Packers fan and admire Brett Favre's love for the game and his enthusiasm. Bottom line though is 1. Joe Montana 2. Terry Bradshaw

Answer 8

Steve Young is not #2...*L*...One Super Bowl...Terry Bradshaw is #2 with 4 like Montana...I'd put Favre ahead of Marino too...

Peyton has one Super Bowl...Brady has 3...Colts fans never learn...*L*...Nick R., get your head out of Peyton's a*s...*L*

Answer 9

Mannning will be when he's done. He'll have most of marino's records and maybe favre's consecutive start streak as well.

And for the GQ boy's worshippers, rings are a team accomplishment and the pats owe those SBs to their defense as much as brady. Terry Bradshaw won 4 superbowls compared to marino's none and bradshaw isn't even in the conversation.

Answer 10

Winning the big game is everything so
Joe montana

Championship Games Played in
NFC Championship Game: 81, 83, 84, 88, 89, 90
AFC Championship Game: 93 (with the chiefs)
Superbowls XVI (81), XIX (84), XXIII (88), XXIV (89)
Honors MVP of Super Bowl: XVI, XIX, XXIV
Named to play in Pro Bowl: 81, 83, 84, 85, 87, 89, 90, 93