Should I take this trade?

Question

A guy in my league wants to tradee me Kellen Winslow Jr for Ernest Graham the running back in Tampa Bay. Is this a fair trade?

My team is as followed:
QBs-T.Romo, T.Green
RBs-T, Bell, F. Gore, B. Jacobs,S. Morris, M. Hicks, E.Graham
WRs-P. Burress, B. Edwards, I. Bruce, T. Cooper
TE- D. Clark
K- A.Vinatieri
Def- Dolphins & Colts

Answer 1

Running backs are always better, but if he's on your bench and Winslow is an improvement over your current TE, do it.

Answer 2

I take this trade in a minute if you need an upgrade at TE.
Reasons:
1. Graham will be splitting carries with Pittman.
2. Tampa is trying to trade for a starting RB. They are talking to Minnesota about Chester Taylor now & will continue to look so Grahams future is not gauranteed.
3. Winslow is a top 2 or 3 TE and gives ya 7-10 pts. every week, hands down. Gates is the only one better.
4. He plays through injuries. He played this past week with a partially seperated shoulder and had almost 100 yds. receiving.
5. If you are strong at RB, what do you need Graham for?

It would help to know what ya had at RB and TE, but if ya have strength at RB, I make this trade easy especially with Cleveland throwing the ball well lately.

Good luck.

Answer 3

Yeah, if you're not relying on Graham that much, pull the trigger. You figure you're getting a top 3 TE, for maybe like the 30th best RB who'll split carries.

Answer 4

Well, its up to you, but Graham will get the bulk of the carries now that Cadillac is out in TB.

Answer 5

Can't make that call on such little information.

Answer 6

go for it its equal

Answer 7

go for it