Deuce Mcalister or Edgerrin James??

Question

Deuce Mcalister vs Bucs Def?
or
Edgerrin James vs Seahawks Def?

Deuce played terribly against the colts but then again the saints r playing against a tampa def that allowed 100+ yards to shaun alexander last week.

And Edge had a good game against the 49ers but im worried whether the o-line can hold off the seahawks d-line

Answer 1

The Seahawks D-line is overrated, especially since they lost DT Marcus Tubbs for the year right before the season started. Both McAlister and Bush were sub-par against the Colts but Bush will be the primary breakout guy.

I'm pretty sure the Cards can put Edge in the spotlight again. Stick with James.

Answer 2

i'd go with edgerrin James. If u see the colts and san francisco, they both played terrific defense. The only running back they Arizona used was edgerrin while the colts used Mcallister and Reggie Bush. Both Mcallister and Bush both couldn't beat the colts defense, and they both split the time. While edgerrin on the other hand was the only running back arizona used. To me James has the talent to pass the seahawks.

Answer 3

Go Duece, Tampa is pitiful and the Saints are out to Unembarass themselves.

Edge is close to washed up I think and Seattles DL and LB's are good.

Answer 4

Take McAllister. He gets all the hard carries (including goal-line duty), and if Arizona had a hard time with San Francisco, Seattle's going to humiliate them.

Answer 5

Id go with edge because I see Bush getting a lot of touches too.

Answer 6

NO QUESTION.

Edge...

Deuce is splitting time... Edge is almost full time. No brainer. Start the Edge.

Answer 7

Deuce. He will get the ball lots..