Donovan McNabb or David Garrard?

Question

I don't know if Donovan will be the McNabb of other years or if David will have another good week?? Who should I put in for week 2?

Answer 1

I'm going to answer this question as though you actually need help and this question was serious, however, I doubt that.

Donovan McNabb is the better QB by far. Almost no matter what, you start the better player over matchups. McNabb did have a bad week last week but he was going against a very good D. GB has two shutdown corners which caused McNabb to go to no name Avant a lot, the 3rd WR because the first 2 where shut down. LJ Smith also wasn't available as a safety valve. This won't happen often as Philadelphia has some of the best offensive minded coaches and they will figure it out. I think they kind of took Green Bay for granted and that hurt them. I like 3 TD's and a 300 yard games out of Donovan this week. I'm not sure if Garrard will ever have a 300 yard game along with 3 TD's.

Don't worry about McNabb

Answer 2

Thats a tough call but mcnabb has history on his side where garrard is save a few starts last year relatively a rookie

Answer 3

mcnabb is too good to pass up on dude. Garrard doesn't have much to throw too, but mcnabb has the TE who has pretty good hands and his receiver core ain't to bad neither. also, Westbrook is gonna get looks with his reliable hands.

Answer 4

mcnabb for sure