Why is german not a permanent member of the security council?

Question

and china is, what were the criterias used?

Answer 1

To concur with the other answers - The permanent members of the UN Security Council are: USA, Great Britain, France, Russia (assuming the seat of the USSR) and China. They were all Allies during WW II.

Answer 2

Article 23 of the UN Charter defines the permanent membership of the Security Council and names each of them. Germany and Japan are considered to be enemies of signatories to the Charter at the time the Charter was signed and later ratified, as defined by Article 107 of the Charter. Any change to the permanent membership of the Security Council must be made by amendment to the Charter as set forth in Article 108 of the Charter. That requires an affirmative vote by two-thirds of the members of the General Assembly, which must be ratified by two-thirds of the members of the UN in accordance with the constitutional processes of their respective countries, including all of the permanent members of the Security Council.

Answer 3

Because the Security Council (as part of the UN) was set up immiediatly following WWII and it had the victors of the war as members plus the successors states (US, UK, France, USSR and Communits China which succedded in 1971 Taiwan). Germany as the loser in WWII was not included thus.

Answer 4

UN SC club (different than the 5 everlasting contributors) comes via rotation & election via different UN contributors (193 contributors) and is for a limited term. Germany too might get it if the different contributors of her region pick her. in case you meant 'everlasting club', my counter-question is why would desire to it, to the exclusion of a few 188 different international places. There are some seventy international places larger than Germany in inhabitants & area. The 5 'everlasting contributors of UN SC have been all Victors of the WW II. Germany & Japan have been the Vanquished. UN all started with 40 9 contributors in 1945. Germany (West Germany or FDR) become admitted in UN in 1973 as one hundred and thirtieth member (Japan as 77th member, in 1956) alongside with Bahamas accompanied (subsequent twelve months) via Bangladesh. interior the reformation of UN SC many standards have been mooted. no longer something particular is rising now. There are a myriad pulls & pushes. For the best dozen or so contesting this UN SC everlasting membershippersistent, there are supporters as properly as detractors to tug that member down, for countless interior reach political reasons. the only qualification for Germany & Japan to stake their declare on the excessive table is that the two are wealthy international places (GDP interior a score of 5), Even right here their scores are slipping each and every year. they have modest defense force. Even in any different case their energetic participation in UN activities are no longer interior the genuine league.

Answer 5

the winners of World War 2 decided to establish the United Nations and give themselves permanent positions
China had fought Japan and got a permanent seat
Germany was punished with less power

Answer 6

The security council was made up of the allies during WWII

Answer 7

Because, as the greatest professional army the world has ever seen. Do you really think the rest of the world wants Germany to rise again? Especially since Germany came very close to winning the entire vorld.

Answer 8

The Germans get a tad restless every few generations.

Answer 9

Because every other time, they declare the war to the world, killing Jews and so on, and not to many people likes that, you know.

Answer 10

Did Germany win WW2 ? This is the key