Is it worth me making THE TRADE?

Question

My team
My team is

Starting
Philip Rivers
Frank Gore
Chris Brown
Steve Smith
Lee Evans
Patrick Crayton
Todd Heap
Shayne Graham
Patriots

reserves

David Garrard
Cadillac Williams
Jerrico Cotchery
Amani Toomer
Anthony Thomas


I would be trading Steve Smith and Chris Brown for Shaun Alexander? It would devastate my receiving corps but my RB's would be great what should I do?

Answer 1

I wouldnt do it. Barring injury your RBs now should be fine. Giving up your recievers like that means you would have to scout for some top notch second tier WRs and hope you get lucky.

Answer 2

I would not make the trade. You are not getting enough back, I would have him throw in another WR. You have to ask yourself would you trade Smith for Alexander straight up. I don't think you can even do that. Your backs arn't that great if Brown was your back up then it makes a little more sense, but with Williams out and Thomas only getting 2-5 touches Brown is your starter. In Fantasy i am always a fan of 2-3 good RBs and a stable of WR's that you can start depending on match-up. So I wouldn't take it but if he threw in a WR that has a chance to produce when he plays a bad DEF i might take it.

Answer 3

I find your giving up way more than what you are receving. I wouldnt do this trade.
But it would also depend on you league. If your league favor RBs then i would say its a coin toss. If it doesnt favor RBs then a sure no.

Smith is a Top 3 reciver and is going to give u big points week in and week out.

Answer 4

No, i would keep them both. Smith is awesome and Brown is going to be good if he doesn't get hurt. I would rather you have LenDale White instead of the A Train.

Answer 5

I would have to wait until after this weeks game to make a choice. I want to see if Brown is the real deal or just had a career day. If he explodes again, its not worth it.