Do you think the McCanns are guilty or innocent?

Question

Do you think the McCanns killed Madeleine or not?

Answer 1

tab i want to ask a question for you every one is saying that the parents killed there daughter in they found blood in the car in hair to but you have to asks your selfs one question ok this simimar event happen to a austrilia parents to they where both acused of killing there baby girl in the mother went to jail for along time because of her innocents in then one day they had found the baby girl in she was killed by a pack of dingo now i want to have every one that reads this question ok asks your selfs how do you know theses people killed there daughter you dont stop pointing your finger at some one just to find them guitly that is how people that get sent to jail every year die just because some one said they did it in it was a lie so read this story down below

On the evening of Sunday, 17 August 1980 Lindy Chamberlain was an innocent, 32 year old mother of two boys, and a girl - Aidan, 6, Reagan, 4, and nine-week-and-four-day-old Azaria. Lindy wanted all of her children to have names with strong meanings, choosing Azaria because the book of baby names she found it in said it meant 'Blessed of God'. It was exactly how she felt finally getting the daughter she had so badly wanted.

The family was staying in the public campground at Ayers Rock (now Uluru). Before the night was over her daughter was to disappear from the tent where she was sleeping. Lindy had seen a dingo coming out of the tent, and when she checked on her daughter, found her gone. There were dingo prints leading into the cold desert night and blood in the tent. But by morning, people who had not been with Lindy comforting her, or searching on that night, were already spreading wild, untrue rumours. Of sacrifice, murder, dingoes not being capable, and of weird behaviour.

There was never a question of the events and evidence on the part of the eyewitnesses – none of whom had met the Chamberlains before – or the rangers, trackers, and police first on the scene. It was a natural tragedy that the head Ranger had warned his government of some time earlier. The first Coroner's Inquest confirmed that a dingo had killed Azaria. That verdict was later overturned, and Lindy was to spend the next seven years living a nightmare – nearly three of them in prison – before finally managing to prove her innocence, and receiving complete exoneration – a first for Australian justice.

As you look at the contents of this website, just for curiosity, or for research, keep foremost in your mind that this is two stories, firstly about a young life cut short. But, it is also the story of a mother who fought for justice, while struggling to keep her family together.

Above all, in everything that you do with your life, keep an open mind…

Answer 2

This is for the courts to decide because unlike us they will have all the evidence before them. So far from what I have heard there is no evidence that is likely to convict them. I think it is right the police consider the possibility of the parents being involved but they should not forget about looking at all other possibilities as well and still look for Madeleine. My feeling is the police just want to throw whatever they can at the parents to try and resolve the case and thereby help mend the immense damage to their tourist industry! I feel this has become political now! The locals in Portugal are fed up with the McCanns because it is ruining their industry.

Answer 3

Guilty. Too many facts, files and documentaries, not to mention books with tons of facts and inconsistencies from the Mccanns. There WAS no abductor, the man suspected of taking her was a father taking his daughter home from night creche, its on wikipedia and in alot of papers as of last year. The man the smiths saw at 10pm taking a child by the beach, matching Madeleine description, looked alot like Gerry which is why they took so long to release the info. Also why would dogs lie? these highly trained blood and cadaver dogs who have caught suspects and found remains of missing people before in all 200 cases and been right, be wrong in this case? 15 out of 19 markers were a match for Madeleine's blood and DNA

Answer 4

to the previous poster about Lindy Chamberlain, this incedent took place in 1980 so cannot be compared to the Madeleine case as DNA and Forensic evidence is far more advanced than what it was back then
from the evidence collect I think that the McCanns had something to do with their daughters murder but wether they did it or not I dont know its hard to say,maybe they know who did and had planned it from the start but only time will tell

Answer 5

Even if they did not directly kill her they are still guilty because they possibly gave some one such an oppurtunity to do it. It is there fault first and foremost for not acting repsonsibly. They did the stupidest thing a parent could ever do.

Answer 6

From the details we have, I'd say guilty. They have never looked particularly devastated to me. Kids do not just disappear without a trace. They know what happened and one is protecting the other.

Answer 7

Guilty, that was my first thought when the child was reported missing. The story sounded fishy from the first moment it was reported.

Answer 8

Alright then Slayer, a Dingo got her, but I'll put money on the fact that those bast ards fed her to it!

Answer 9

They left their children alone and unattended. I am sure for the rest of their living days they will deeply regret this.
Are they murders? No I don't think they are.

Answer 10

I do not know, however even if they are guilty, they are innocent until pr oven otherwise.