Was this a good trade?

Question

I didn't get many responses early this morning...tell me what you think!
I traded Roy Williams and Marion Barber for Rudi Johnson. Now I have...
I HAVE TO START 3 WR
WR ANDRE JOHNSON
WR SANTONIO HOLMES
WR JERRICHO COTCHERY
PICKING UP ON WAIVERS
WR DEVERY HENDERSON
WR BRANDON MARSHALL

I HAVE TO START 2 RB's
RB WILLIS MCGAHEE
RB RUDI JOHNSON
RB DEANGELO WILLIAMS
RB JAMAL LEWIS
RB DERRICK WARD

Thanks for your answer Dodge. Very insightful I had a late round draw so I took Peyton at QB in the first and McGahee for second. Just couldn't pass on Manning.

Answer 1

I think you did well. You are banking on Cotchery, Marshall or Henderson to explode later, and I think Marshall will. Meanwhile, the Rudi/Willis tandem should have your opponents looking for a solid response in haste.

I'm not high on either Ward or Williams due to the committee thing. And Jamal Lewis has the Cleveland QB monkey on his back.

Answer 2

Awesome trade!
Start
WR - Andre Johnson, Santonio Holmes, Cotchery
RB - Rudi Johnson, Willis McGahee

Try and trade Jamal Lewis and get something valuable for him like a better WR. Pick up Pittman from TB from FA.