Who Should I Give Up for Vincent Jackson?

Question

I have already come to HATE the autodraft but oh well it got me Payton and now i can deal him away fo a top RB. (Payton and Bush for Bulger and Addai in the works)

Heres my WR that i could trade, Donte Stallworth and Santionio Holmes. I know they are rated higher than him but i have faith in Jackson.

but would trading Stallworth strait up seem a little odd knowing that im droping in ranking?

Payton is not always the Number 1 QB. Bulger had 96 less yards and 6 less TD and 1 less INT. In my League that translates to 23 more points and not even 1.5 a game. Addai is the ONLY rusher in Ind and Bush shares time w/ Duece and people seem to ALWAYS forget.

Answer 1

i would give up stallworth for vincent jackson. got him on my squad. personaly i think holmes and jackson are gunna have above average years for their teams. this is the year they need to make a name for themselves...good or bad.

Answer 2

Donte Stallworth is injury prone and in an offense where Brady throws to everyone except the waterboy. Santonio Holmes is the second receiver with Hines Ward and Roethlisberger isn't rated very high this year.

But, Jackson is the Chargers' #1 wideout and Rivers is throwing the ball extremely well this year. I'm biased (SD fan). But, I would take Jackson over either of those two any day.

Answer 3

I agree they are rate higher than him, but from the 2 WR you listed I say go ahead and trade D Stallworth for him. I think S Holmes will do pretty good this year. GOOD LUCK

Answer 4

Are you trading Peyton Manning and Reggie Bush for Bulger and Addai???? I would NEVER trade Peyton, and Bush should have a great year. Peyton is the #1 QB and Bush and Addai are about even, so why trade?

Regarding Vincent Jackson, he isn't even the Charger's #1 receiver - Gates and LT are. So why trade for him?

Answer 5

keep holmes cause he might break a punt return for an extra touchdown one of these weeks.