Is this a good fantasy trade for me?

Question

This is the trade, my reggie wayne for his willis mcgahee. this is the rest of my team, P.Manning, Marc Bulger, Julius Jones, Dominic Rhodes, Adrian Peterson(MIN), M.Colston, Donte' Stallworth, Antonio Bryant, Rickey Proehl, Vernon Davis, O.Mare(K), Pats D and Raiders D. The league Iam in is nfl.com.

Answer 1

-thanks my man-

as for your question....I'd consider getting rid of one of your QBs for a top RB or WR

if you get a good Receiver, take the trade
if you get a good Running Back, don't take the trade

the way I see it...you need help at RB, McGahee would be that help....but then you'd be somewhat weak at WR (although I'd much rather be weak at WR than RB)
you don't need 2 top QBs and before the season starts, I'm sure either one of them would have great trade value.


good luck

Answer 2

Your team needs some RB help immediately. I'd consider trading Peyton Manning for a solid RB and a solid WR from another team. Your team has too many holes at other positions and you have Mark Bulger and can grab another QB.

Colston is an interesting catch, but reviews on what kind of season he'll have are mixed. This site claims he won't have as solid of a year as in 2006, which means you might want to consider dealing him:

http://www.fantasyfanatics.com/index.php?fuseaction=articles.view&catagory=Draft%20Guide&article=68

Answer 3

yes u need a tier 1 RB, Rhodes is suspended 4 games...Adrian is a rookie splitting carries with chester, Julius is also sharing with Marion Barber, you need a strong RB on your team to survive every week. Willis is a 2nd-3rd round pick, and so is Reggie Wayne. It seems to be a fair trade.

Answer 4

No do not give up Wayne for Mcgahee.
You got Manning(Pocket QB) will pass it all day
and one of those main guys its Wayne
and Give up Dominic Rhodes. he wont be playing for 6 weeks.

Answer 5

Live and Die by the RB position.

I'd take the deal.

Answer 6

yes cuz u really need rb

Answer 7

no