should I trade shaun alexander for steve smith?

Question

should I trade shaun alexander for steve smith? I have shaun, marooney, and travis henry as rbs and randy moss, larry fitzgerald, and deion branch as wrs.

Answer 1

No way! Smith is awesome but I cant see giving away an elite RB for an elite WR ever. The Seahawks will give S.A. plenty of running room now that Hasselback is healthy along with S.A. being healthy. If Alexander plays anywhere near the season before he easily doubles the points any receiver can score. Plus Maroney needs to prove he can handle the full workload (I think he can but if he struggles with wearing down, injury,etc. you only have 1 strong RB....you just eliminate yourself from having a shot at 1st). It is far easier to get steady production from a receiver off the free agent list year after year (who knew going into last year a guy like Mike Furrey would go for well over 1000 yards?). Like i said....Smith is awesome but not worth gambling a premeire running back for on the injury risk alone. If Alexander returns to his form of 2 years ago he is without a doubt a top 3 running back.

Answer 2

Good trade in almost every money league S.A. is falling and you have 2 quality RBs, the #1 rated WR is a good deal.

Answer 3

quite choose for it! Smith is the suitable WR and Alexander would be question marked for something of the season by using fact of his foot. as long as you're sturdy in RB, quite choose for the commerce.

Answer 4

Yes. Definitely do it before you can't anymore. Maroney and Henry should be solid enough because you are getting Steve Smith. Yes, yes, yes.

Answer 5

yeah u should u got 2 other great RB but and you could use a great WR

Answer 6

no