Is the difference between Magic and Man the amount of noise it makes?

Answer 1

so you are saying if a tree falls down in the forest and no one is around it does in fact make a noise?!

Answer 2

The only difference is we think we know man because we ARE man and magic by ONE definition is a happening for which we have no description for its cause or determinant and therefor can not exercise control or power upon it for our use. But of course mans power over man is magic to some, and the actions recorded in human history are for some inexplicable horrors and beauty.


The Will is positive, the Judgment is negative.

'Nature engenders nature, and nature only, in its reproduction and in its life. The rose brings forth more roses, never anything ‘unnatural’ or ‘unrose-like’. The human being creates humanity, but with this difference: what is human can at the same time be either ‘human’ or ‘inhuman’. The results of human action range from creations which fill our hearts and souls with lasting strength and delight, to crimes whose shame no atonement can wipe off the face of the earth.'

http://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/ge/bublitz.htm

Ute Bublitz (1998)

Beyond Philosophy
Reconciliation and Rejection
Three Essays on Aristotle and Hegel

Answer 3

Magic has no sound, so, there's a difference. Man makes noise, & also beautiful sounds.

Answer 4

Well magic does not make noise. It is more like a miracle of supernatural or scientific origin, which we simply do not understantd - yet. Man on the other hand is often partner with chaos. Each struggles with himself/ herself and with everyone else. We surprise each other with our illogical behavior, our chaos, our noise.

Answer 5

I think the difference is more to do with who the man is first.
If the man is great then he's magic but if not then the magic still reigns supreme.

Answer 6

Is this in English?

Answer 7

if you think so, yes it is

Answer 8

YEA