Is this fair or not?

Question

laveraneus coles jamal lewis and antonio gates FOR donald driver edgerrin james and ronnie brown. please put a yes or a no then your reasoning

Answer 1

WOW! I would love to be the guy who gets edge, driver, and brown. All three of those guys are far better than coles or lewis, and TE is highly overrated. Gates is nice to have, but he's not gonna put up monster numbers, and you are improving significantly at the other spots.

Answer 2

We can't exactly say yes or no to be sure because we don't know your other players on your team.

I would say it is a pretty good trade in general though. You would be giving up the best TE in football in Antonio Gates though and your not getting one in return. I would like to know who your back-up TE is so I could give you a better answer with that part of the trade. You would be getting a better WR in Donald Driver but he does have an injury to his foot but it isn't expected to have a change for his status for the start of the season but I would watch him closely. You also would be getting two really good RB's in James and Brown. James should have a good season ahead of him but I am not sure how Brown will do considering the Dolphins have a pretty weak OL. In my opinion, either one of them is an improvement over Lewis.

Overall, you are getting more than your giving. If you have a good back up TE, then do the trade. If you don't, I would keep my players and move on. Good luck with the trade and the upcoming season!

Answer 3

the guy who gets Driver, James, and Brown is a lucky man. Those guys are better than Coles, Lewis, and Gates. Only problem is that the gut who gives Gates needs to have a back up, and the guy who gives Driver, James, and Brown must not have a good TE.

Answer 4

Ummm, YES. jump on that trade!