Who do you think are the top 5 QBs today?

Question

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. McNabb
4. Palmer
5. Brees

Answer 1

1. Tom Brady
2. Payeton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Carson Palmer
5. Tony Romo

Answer 2

1 Romo
2 Manning
3 Brady
4 Palmer
5 Brees

Answer 3

These are my 5 QB's today:

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. McNabb
4. Palmer
5. Brees

Answer 4

1. Manning - This is the only guy where you don't need an offensive coordinator and the team would be just as efficient. He's too damn talented and works too hard to not be #1
2. Brady- Hard to argue with 3 superbowl rings and the closest thing to a dynasty that we may ever see again in football
3. Brees - Payton loves to throw the ball. Brees is a smart player that will put up big numbers again.
4. Palmer - Could be above Brees but seems to get hurt a lot. Has talent to be the #2 guy on this list
5. Bulger - Another guy that gets bitten by the injury bug. Plays at a pro bowl level when he does play. (he plays in more games each year, otherwise Mcnabb would beat him out)

Answer 5

1 Brady (more rings then any QB in the league)
2 Manning (prepares better then any1, great arm)
3 Palmer (won heismen & then turned the bengals around 180 degrees)
4 Bulger (underrated & plays for 1 of the best passing offenses)
5 Brees (showed what he can do last year & has more weapons then any other player, but isn't as proven as bulger)

Answer 6

1. Peyton Manning - The guy is going to own just about every record in the NFL before all is said and done. Brady is right up there as well and its hard to argue against him being #1. Brady is the new Joe Montana, Manning is the new Dan Marino except Manning has won a Super Bowl. I put Peyton number one just because I think he is the better pure passer of the two.

2. Tom Brady - Can't argue with 3 Super Bowl rings. I used to think that it was mostly because of the loaded talent around him, but after watching him over the years he is probably the coolest and calmest QB in the league; and he has a lazer of an arm too. He will probably win another Superbowl or two before its all said and done.

3. Donavan McNabb - Four consecutive NFC Championship games. The guy produces year in and year out when healthy; but that has been a problem for him the past couple of years. And he has done it without the excellent talent on offense.

4. Carson Palmer - Great leader, great passer. He has the weapons all around him which make his job a lot easier and he could be a Superbowl QB if the defense would step up and start producing some results.

5. Drew Brees - I thought this guy was going to be a bust after a couple of bad seasons in San Diego but he has proven me wrong and has turned out to be one of the NFL's premier QB's. He had two great seasons in San Diego and followed a shoulder surgery up with a phenomenal year in New Orleans. He is well on his way to proving that he is one of the best QB's in the league and he has the offensive talent to get it done.

Anyone who said Tony Romo is on crack. He's good but he hasn't even started full season yet.

Answer 7

Manning, Brady, Palmer, Brees and Hasselback. They all are durable and know what to do at the right time.

McNabb is a good QB but not in the top 5 any longer, not durable enough and still hits receivers in the shoe tops instead of the letters.

Answer 8

Winner wise I like the order except for Brees.
Stats wise as follows:

NAME COM ATT PCT YDS YPA LNG TD TD% INT INT% SK SYD RAT
1 P. Manning QB, IND 362 557 65.0 4397 7.89 68 31 5.6 9 1.6 14.0 86 101.0
2 D. Huard QB, KAN 148 244 60.7 1878 7.70 78 11 4.5 1 .4 16.0 106 98.0
3 Drew Brees QB, NOR 356 554 64.3 4418 7.98 86 26 4.7 11 2.0 18.0 105 96.2
4 D. McNabb QB, PHI 180 316 57.0 2647 8.38 87 18 5.7 6 1.9 21.0 140 95.5
5 Tony Romo QB, DAL 220 337 65.3 2903 8.61 56 19 5.6 13 3.9 21.0 124 95.1
6 C. Palmer QB, CIN 324 520 62.3 4035 7.76 74 28 5.4 13 2.5 36.0 233 93.9
7 M. Bulger QB, STL 370 588 62.9 4301 7.32 67 24 4.1 8 1.4 49.0 366 92.9
8 P. Rivers QB, SDG 284 460 61.7 3388 7.37 57 22 4.8 9 2.0 27.0 144 92.0
9 Tom Brady QB, NWE 319 516 61.8 3529 6.84 62 24 4.7 12 2.3 26.0 175 87.9
10 M. Brunell QB, WAS 162 260 62.3 1789 6.88 74 8 3.1 4 1.5 12.0 92 86.5
11 J. Losman QB, BUF 268 429 62.5 3051 7.11 83 19 4.4 14 3.3 47.0 332 84.9
12 C. Pennington QB, NYJ 313 485 64.5 3352 6.91 71 17 3.5 16 3.3 30.0 172 82.6
13 J. Delhomme QB, CAR 263 431 61.0 2805 6.51 72 17 3.9 11 2.6 22.0 167 82.6
14 S. McNair QB, BAL 295 468 63.0 3050 6.52 87 16 3.4 12 2.6 14.0 84 82.5
15 David Carr QB, HOU 302 442 68.3 2767 6.26 53 11 2.5 12 2.7 41.0 240 82.1
16 D. Garrard QB, JAC 145 241 60.2 1735 7.20 49 10 4.1 9 3.7 20.0 119 80.5
17 Jon Kitna QB, DET 372 596 62.4 4208 7.06 60 21 3.5 22 3.7 63.0 388 79.9
18 E. Manning QB, NYG 301 522 57.7 3244 6.22 55 24 4.6 18 3.4 25.0 186 77.0
19 M. Hasselbeck QB, SEA 210 371 56.6 2442 6.58 72 18 4.9 15 4.0 34.0 229 76.0
20 M. Vick QB, ATL 204 388 52.6 2474 6.38 55 20 5.2 13 3.4 45.0 303 75.7
21 B. Roethlisberger QB, PIT 280 469 59.7 3513 7.49 67 18 3.8 23 4.9 46.0 280 75.4
22 A. Smith QB, SFO 257 442 58.1 2890 6.54 75 16 3.6 16 3.6 35.0 202 74.8
23 M. Leinart QB, ARI 214 377 56.8 2547 6.76 58 11 2.9 12 3.2 21.0 158 74.0
24 R. Grossman QB, CHI 262 480 54.6 3193 6.65 62 23 4.8 20 4.2 21.0 142 73.9
25 B. Favre QB, GNB 343 613 56.0 3885 6.34 82 18 2.9 18 2.9 21.0 134 72.7
26 B. Johnson QB, MIN 270 439 61.5 2750 6.26 46 9 2.1 15 3.4 29.0 200 72.0
27 C. Frye QB, CLE 252 393 64.1 2454 6.24 75 10 2.5 17 4.3 44.0 262 72.0
28 J. Plummer QB, DEN 175 317 55.2 1994 6.29 83 11 3.5 13 4.1 18.0 111 68.8
29 J. Harrington QB, MIA 223 388 57.5 2236 5.76 48 12 3.1 15 3.9 15.0 116 68.2
30 V. Young QB, TEN 184 357 51.5 2199 6.16 53 12 3.4 13 3.6 25.0 129 66.7
31 B. Gradkowski QB, TAM 177 328 54.0 1661 5.06 53 9 2.7 9 2.7 25.0 146 65.9
32 A. Walter QB, OAK 147 276 53.3 1677 6.08 51 3 1.1 13 4.7 46.0 256 55.8

Answer 9

1. Peyton Manning (future hall of famer for sure, throws great, and he has led a team to the superbowl.)
2. Tom Brady (He will be the best after Peyton Manning retires, he is young, and yet he is the 2nd best QB in the entire nation, maybe the world.)
3. Phillip Rivers (this guy is going to have another breakout season with LT running game intimidating opponents enough for him to throw for atleast 150 yards a game.)
4. Drew Brees- Leading the Cinderella team, the Saints, he will have an impressive year with the duo of him and Reggie Bush, this teamup is simliar to the Chargers LT/Rivers match.
5. Tony Romo- He is young and yet he led the Cowboys in a midseason turnaround that landed them into the playoffs. He only played for about half of the season, but this year, he will start in every game this season and he will have a great season.

Answer 10

No particular order but Favre is #1 on the list because he is the BEST!

Favre-there is no QB in the league that plays with as much heart and skill as he does.

Manning-last year was a great season for him and he is always consistent

Brady-after all the superbowl wins, he has done something right even though he cant win them on his own

Brees-he is pretty consistent

Grossman (lol) I had to put that one in there since noone else did

Answer 11

Looks like Manning, Brady, Palmer, and Brees are locks in most people's votes. I won't argue that. I'll go with Mark Bulger as my #5, though... but that is factoring in health. Otherwise I'd go with McNabb, presuming he can even last more than five games this year.