Who would you rather have, Eli Manning or Rex Grossman?

Question

If you had to choose Eli or Rex for you real team or fantasy team, how would you choose and why?

Answer 1

I would rather have Eli Manning because in the pre-season Rex Grossman has been fumbling too many passes and in-completing them when he doesn't fumble them so Eli Manning is my pick.

Answer 2

Rex over Eli. Rex has shown that he can be a great QB. But than he has a game where he looks like he doesn't know what he is doing. Eli looks clueless all the time. If Rex can just learn how to take a snap and not throw to the other team. He would be okay.

Answer 3

Rex Grossman. He is up and donw and has a fumbleing and int problem. That was his full season. This was Eli's second so Eli had more xp. Grossman has a better post season reord (2-2) that manning (0-2). WHen Grossman plays well hes an mvp like player.

Answer 4

Wow, what a choice, the bad or the worse...

I personally would go with Eli, just because Grossman statistically puts up more interceptions than Manning. Grossman is just so unpredictable that I wouldn't feel safe putting my hopes on him. At least with Manning there is a certain amount of consistency, even if his results are not that great.

Answer 5

I'd go with Eli, I think he'll put up better stats than Grossman. I think he will throw less INT's. They both suck though. But if I had to pick between the two of them, if god hated me so much that he only left me Rex Grossman and Eli Manning to play QB for my team, I would go with Eli.

Answer 6

hey TFoley, what media market wouldn't give a QB a rough time when he has 5 games under a 40 QB rating and ties for 2nd in QB turnovers for the season?

Take Eli. You can blame the misfit poorly coached team for his woes but the Bears have a very solid team which actually found a way to win a couple of those games in which Grossman had under a 40 QB rating.

Answer 7

Neither to tell you the truth, but if I had to choose, I would take Eli over Grossman.

Answer 8

I hate Eli Manning, but as far as fantasy- i'd pick Eli instead of Gross Gross Grossman. He put up a lousy fantasy record last year. That being said, neither, but if you have to choose of course Manning.

Answer 9

I'm a Bear fan, but I'm ready to throw Rex under the bus . Not being able to handle the center snap is just plain $#@&^%. At this point I'd take Manning because of Rex's stupid , habitual basic mistakes.

Answer 10

Eli, who may have respectible numbers each week and is good for at least two big games....Grossman is best handing the ball off, that is if he can handle the center snap.