who is the most worthless American Idol contestant who doesn't seem to be hateable?

Question

who among the American Idol from any season is the suckiest and most ineligible who everyone seems to like and think that his/her voice is excellent but really is not.

sanjaya and the other irritating wannabes are not possible answers. sanjaya's voice was never thought of by any sane-thinking person as something excellent. it's never even near a perfectly human voice!

answer with humor and entertainingly.

this is a survey for a new reality show on FOX.


by the way, your answer should not be someone who isn't hateable but not necessarily loveable in public perspective.

Answer 1

william hung.