2 silver dollar coins I have cleaned them well but there are still just one or two tarnish spots on them.?

Question

They are from 1921 and 1923. They have AMAZING detail. very very light scratches here and there and small tarnished areas. (very small areas). Any idea on the value?

Answer 1

You damaged them by cleaning them and all they are worth now is the value of the silver in them. A dealer may give you 7 times face value. They are no longer a collector item. The main rule in coin collection is do not clean the coins. I have seen a $500 coin turn into a $25 coin do to harsh cleaning, scratches are considered harsh cleaning no matter how small they are. There would have been more detail if you had not cleaned them.