Why most of Indian Muslims will think, they are belongs to Pakisthan ?

Answer 1

Mr. Ravi Kumar,

You are absolutely wrong. How many Indians Muslims have you interviewed?

Answer 2

It is not true.
Muslims have been here since the 7th century A D.Muslims rulers have been ruling over large parts of India for nearly800 years.At no time then there was any communal clash.Hindus and Muslims jointly fought against the British during 1957.The Britsh Raj that followed evolved the "divide and rule"policy.
In the beginning they befriended the Hindus and offered a lot of benefits.When the freedom struggle arose, they changed colour and pampered the Muslims.
In the railway station one person served"Hindu pani" and another "Muslim pani'!And there were separate eateries for each community!
Since 1927 India was made a hotbed of communal clashes.
Hence,the Muslims wanted reservations and separate electorate. The British willingly obliged.
During World War II (1939- 45) congress launched "quit India" movement. All congress party leaders wer jailed for 3 years.In 1946 Jinnah launche direct action that led to communal clashes in Noakhali(E.Bengal). folowed by country wide communal carnage.At that time British decided to divide the country and make an exit.There were exodus of population between India and Pakistan..
After Independence congress came to pwer and was bent upon development works. The oppositin kept the people reminded of the trauma of partition to gain political mileage!
They let the Hindu youh to call on Muslims to go to Pakistan.!
This is yhe incotrovertible truth.

Answer 3

India was never a united coutry. It was a big area governed by many Hindu Rajas. First time the Budhist kings combined major parts to a country for some time. Then muslims governed whole of Indian sub-continent for one thousand years peacefully and Afghanistan was a part of that great muslim state. Later British came and they colonised India except Afghanistan area of India. When they left they separated it in two states depending on the majority of hindu or muslims. Muslims of India are brother of Pakistani muslims they should be proud of it, beside this they are Indian too, the past kings of India. Although a minority now. Muslims are not bound to country, they are bound to religion. We can say Saudia is our country and surely it is but beside this we are faithful to our country (land) also.

Answer 4

Who said that?

More than 2 billion Muslim live in every part of every country in the world. He never has to think about Pakistan. The question shows your ignorance. If at all a muslim has to think about another country they will think of some rich country. Why the poor and politically torn Pakistan?

Muslims taught others what is patriotism. In Kargil among the dead 40% were muslims as against 10% in the army

Answer 5

I think its not that indian muslims think they belong to Pakistan, but hindus making them feel they dont belong to India. I have observed that indian muslims are treated like stepchildren of India. For the majority of hindus the muslims of India are foreign substances.
I am not a great defender of Islam or any other religion, but a defender of equality for all minorities. It should be commonly accepted that India is diverse... that it is not a contradiction to be a muslim Indian, an christian Indian... or even an atheist Indian.

Answer 6

If their parents, grandparents etc did what most Hindus and Sikhs did during partition by escaping to India, these Muslims would have been Pakistani today. Had this happen it would have done India the world of good as it would have distributed the migration issue more fairly.

Answer 7

If you do not intermix the religion and politics, there is no problem.

Only the politicians create the problem, the people will always find a way to live peacefully. A few rocks in the river water do cause a disturbance but are not able to impede the flow of water.

Answer 8

Just read the views of SAHAR. " Indian Muslims are Brothers of Paki Muslims and should be proud of It"
A typical pakistani hates India. yet INdian Muslims are loyal to India! Does that make sense?
Now to answer this you will get bull like an average Paki loves India. RIGHT.
From day one (I am now 60) we have been watching Indian Muslims loyalty to Pakistan in India and abroad. If at least they confess that quite a lot of them are pro Pakistan we would put more faith in them.

Answer 9

Will think?Dear you are Asking about Future,Please Don't worry India future is Bright.
And if some people say they belongs to Pak ask them to go.
by the way you did Serve? of how many people

Answer 10

U r wrong. U give open choice to any muslim and whether one would like to leave India for any Muslim Country, u will find that no one wants to leave India. What respect and dignity of life they r enjoying in India they will not get anywhere.