commented on 300 and some said sin city beats everything?

Question

is it any good, i am down loading it now. dont have much time to watch films, havent even heard of sin city.

thanks

Answer 1

welp, i haven't seen 300 yet, and i have seen sin city, and i still would be very unlikely to say that Sin City 'beats everything.' it's ok, that's all. very gross too. too much for me. worth seeing at least once, and neat the visual effects, but 'beats everything'? no way.

Answer 2

I have seen 300 and Sin City and I would say without a doubt that Sin City beats 300. I don't know about it beating everything, but Sin City and 300 were both amazing movies. Sin City, I think, had a much deeper and more involved storyline. It was also much more centered around the characters and explaining each character's story.

Answer 3

Out of the two I´d watch 300 over and over again. Sin City totally depressed me and was a bit odd. Parts of it were good, but overall, I would not say it beats everything.

Answer 4

Sin City is a much better film, as he can do as he chooses with the plot.

300, although good, gets a D- for the historical content

Answer 5

Sin City has a better story line. It is also from a graphic novel, both from the same guy.

Answer 6

Much better than 300, but it's a totally different kind of movie. The fimography is similar, but the plot is more like a twisted version of 'Pulp Fiction' or 'Magnolia'. It's the kind of movie where the characters' lives intersect and the stories intertwine, but there are 3 distinct plot lines. Good flick, I highly reccomend it.

Answer 7

sin city is a better film why dont you down load that instead

Answer 8

Sin city is good,but not the best ive seen.

Answer 9

To me, they're both just ok..dont get your hopes up w/ neither one..although sin city is a little better.

Answer 10

Sin city was much better!!the story was much more clever and original,worth checking out.