Why are some people here convinced that Osama bin Laden is dead?

Question

What proof is there that he is deceased?

Answer 1

Obviously, it can only be rumors...but there is a lot of logic to those rumors. There is no body, so there can be no definitive proof.

I am also of the opinion that Bin Laden is dead. He was on ongoing kidney dialysis before he had to go into hiding. It is commonly believed that he had to live in the mountains of Pakistan...not a place where you can get regular access to dialysis. Eventually, that would kill you...certainly over a span of 6 years.

From a propaganda and PR perspective, it serves Al Qaeda's interests to keep the specter of Bin Laden alive. So I'm sure when (and if) he died, his body was buried some place where no one except those in his inner circle would ever know.

Answer 2

We don't know for sure as there isn't any concrete proof, as in, a body. But, he was reportedly on dialysis shortly after 9-11. Most people know that dialysis is used when people are in kidney failure, and is only a temporary solution until a transplant is done or just simply prolonging life for a few more years. It's not a permanent thing, people die eventually because machines are no substitutes for internal organs.

Besides, if you've ever seen a dialysis machine, they are about the size of a small refrigerator, not to mention the supplies to do the procedure. How would he drag all of that around the desert?

Answer 3

he's ineffective. the biggest evidence will come whilst bin weighted down fails to concern a video taped rebuttal to information of his dying. If this have been a hoax by using the U. S. government, all bin weighted down could could desire to do is to look on a video tape describing the activities of his meant killing as stated interior the press, and postpone a cutting-edge information paper to teach he remains alive. the U. S. could then look like the worldwide's best butt-wipe. Having taken this under consideration, it form of feels silly to even assume this tale is a pretend, on the grounds that bin weighted down himself ought to teach it to be so common by using resurfacing with a clean video in some days or even weeks. With that for the time of suggestions, i think of you may fairly a lot wager that is one hundred% precise. there is one photograph which has been debunked as a pretend showing a supposedly ineffective bin weighted down. The face precisely fits comparable to his face and beard from a 1998 photograph.

Answer 4

Well, he was kind of a loudmouth while he was alive- releasing videos taunting America about once a week or so... Seen anything recently? I realize that isn't proof at all, but I personally find it suspicious.

Answer 5

I don’t know but, it doesn't really matter. This obsession with OBL is MIND NUMBING! He is not the end all target for this war we are in.

Please consider reading about the Muslim Brotherhood:
Founded in 1928 by the Egyptian activist Hasan al-Banna, the Sunni Muslim Brotherhood is one of the oldest, largest and most influential Islamist organizations. Egypt has historically been the center of the Brotherhood’s operations, though the group maintains offshoots throughout the Arab-Muslim world -- including in Afghanistan, Bahrain, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, the Palestinian territories (Hamas), Saudi Arabia, Syria, and Sudan -- and is also active in the United States and Europe. Islam expert Robert Specer has called the Muslim Brotherhood "the parent organization of Hamas and al Qaeda."

Answer 6

Most of the people who think this way are Republican. They think this way because they are in denial as to why Bush refuses to catch or kill bin Laden.

It's another Republican conspiracy theory: That Bush is so stupid, he's actually smart. So smart that he knows that bin Laden is dead, so he doesn't have to do anything about it.

Answer 7

The is no proof you can hold in your hand. But consider this.
How did he look the last time you saw him. Almost dead right.?
They have admitted he needed dialysis. Where was he going to get it?
Wasn't he the best tool to get his troops energized? If he were alive his videos would be on Al Jazeera instead of Al-Zawahri doing them.

Answer 8

There is no proof and I'm not 100% convinced that he is. However, because of his kidney problems and failing health, years ago, it wouldn't surprise me to discover that he is dead.

Answer 9

I think he's had plastic surgery and is living in the White House as part of the President's personal lawn maintenance staff...

Answer 10

There is no evidence to support it. It could possibly be a rumor born of the fact Bush cannot and will not catch him.