Asking a reference letter from a professor who's course you didn't do well in?

Question

Is that acceptable?

Or if he specialises in a field that you got a C, even though that was not the class he taught you?

Answer 1

If you are talking about a reference to grad school or some academic pursuit, it isn't a good idea. If it is for a job, and the things you did poorly on in his class have no bearing on the job, and he realizes this, then maybe.

I've had students who got poor to average grades ask me for references to grad school and law school at the universities of which I am an alumna, on the assumption that somehow my reference would be advantageous to them because I went to the school. I've had to say no to some of them, because I honestly couldn't recommend say that I thought they would do well. A professor needs to be honest. If he says that you were at best an average student, it won't benefit you in any way.

Answer 2

That's risky. The best advice I can give you is something a professor in a professional development class taught us - whenever you want to ask people for a reference, ask them if they can give you a positive reference. Talk to them and make sure you highlight all your positive qualities. If you made some mistakes, tell them what you've learned from them and what you've done to rectify the situation. If someone is unwilling or unsure of whether or not he/she can give you a positive recommendation, then you'll know and you can move on to someone else who is willing. Your best bet are the professors whose classes you did well in. Good luck.

Answer 3

I wouldn't. I would at least have a b before i ask. But if you knew the professor to the point that he or she would have something nice to say about your effort then go ahead.

Answer 4

hmm idk i'd ask someone else