who's better mcnabb or tom brady?

Question

i say mcnabb

Answer 1

Brady. And not just cause of the rings. He makes better use of his recievers and makes better decisions. I like Mcnabbs mobility but at this point you have to question his ability to give you a full 16 game schedule

Answer 2

How is it McNabb? I mean is he not the same QB that was walking in his only superbowl appearance late in the game when time is a factor? Brady has orchestrated three SB come from behind final points to win score. Pro Bowls and Stats are similiar so you have to look at wins and BIG wins and there are no bigger wins than Championship games and SB wins. Where Tom is 3-1 and Donnie 1-4. So yeah I would take Brady over McNabb all day

Answer 3

Tom Brady has the 3 rings, McNabb hasnt proven himself really

Answer 4

Donovan McNabb is a more athletically gifted player in terms of mobility and has shown greater ability to be effective carrying an entire team on his shoulders. Often resulting in personal injury, and often leading to the Pro Bowl, but not the Superbowl.

Tom Brady is a better pure quarterback, perhaps one of the best I've seen at completing the task at hand under pressure. Tom Brady is also a multiple-time Superbowl champion and MVP.

If you are wondering who is a better QB historically I would have to undoubtedly say Tom Brady. If you are looking for who is a better QB for fantasy football McNabb does more himself to generate points.

If you want a simple answer, one or the other, than the answer is Tom Brady.

Answer 5

McNabb can not say healthy for the whole season. This means the Brady is the better player. He doesn't get hurt and he is one of the top three QBs in the NFL.

Answer 6

Brady in a landslide. He won three superbowls with no running game and very average receivers. Brady is a master at managing games. He is probably the most accurate passer in the NFL. Brady is amazing in the playoffs when it matters most. McNabb is good but I wouldn't begin to consider him as great. He is a good underneath passer but has always struggled with the deep ball. Both are great leaders that inspire their teams. Now that McNabb has had injury problems, his mobility isn't what it used to be.

Answer 7

while this is all mentioned and accomplished - Brady will bypass down as between the applicable quarterbacks of all time. this is not important if Brady never performs yet another game returned and McNabb leads the league in passing yards for the subsequent 5 years, one concern will continually differentiate those 2 adult adult males: Brady - 3 rings McNabb -....... there is your answer.

Answer 8

here's another one of them inbreeds how many super-bowls game has mcnabb been in?????? he is a OK QB not a TOM BRADY WATCH THE SUPER BOWL AND I'LL BET BRADY WILL BE THERE WAY BEFORE McNABB

Answer 9

Brady, I can't believe this is a serious question. McNabb is always injured, is a poor playoff preformer, and occasionally gets a ten yard run. Brady is a damn good quarterback.

Answer 10

I would say Mcnabb but he is just coming off of knee surgery and he is older than Tom Brady. Also Brady has so many weapons this year, Moss, Stallworth, Welker, Moroney, Watson so i say Brady right now.