Illegal to sell alchohol if your with a minnor?

Question

So I live in california and today my friend and i was just driving him around to do some stuff and just hung out hes also my cousins husband well hes 27 and im 18. So our last stop was at Rite Aid and he wanted to get some beer so he went and got it and im just following him we go up to the reggister and the man asked for his ID he showed him and im just minding my own buisness and he askes for mine and i tell him im under 21 and im just driving him around so the man says "im sorry but its against the law, we cant sell you this beer because you are with a minnor" so my friend start to kinda argue with him and i just tell him lets go. So we get in the car and he gets out to talk to the manager but there is no manager and the only other person working agrees with the man. So is what he saying true even if your over 21 and have and ID and money you cant buy alchohol if you have a minnor with you?

thanks

oh yeah and he also didnt state he was refusing to seve to us he only said it was against the law to sell if you in the presence of a minnor

Answer 1

There is nothing in the California Business and Professions Code Section 25657-25658 which deals with the sale of alcohol that says you can't purchase alcohol while in the presence of a minor.

If the minor consumes the alcohol later, then both people are guilty of a misdemeanor, but that wasn't the case.

There may be a new law that states that changes this (doubt it), but remember that the clerks have a right to refuse service for any reason.

Answer 2

The business is a private corporation and has the right to sell anything to anyone for any reason, except if they demonstrate a pattern or prejudice by refusing to sell to parties in a certain EEOC protected class.

In this instance, as the above poster indicated, the clerk erred on the side of caution, which nearly all clerks have now been trained to do to avoid any potential liability on their store's part of getting alcohol into the hands of a minor.

The solution, as you gave your buddy above, was a simple one, take his business elsewhere. Drive him to a liquor store, have him go in by himself and he can buy whatever he wants.

The only exception that has been challenged in the Courts with a successful outcome is that a pharacist cannot refuse to sell a prescription for birth control pills or the "day after" pill to a woman, who has a valid prescription, because doing so violates their religious beliefs.

Answer 3

I desire it became unlawful, yet prohibition did no longer flow so nicely final time. Prohibition is like preserving a wolf by way of the ears. Alcohol is a type of issues which will persist no remember what, so making it unlawful could actual be worse. What we ought to continuously do is aim human beings and help them conquer the will for alcohol. the only reason there is a lot alcohol available is by technique of the fact there's a extreme call for for it. reducing off the provision could only advance the call for, so we ought to continuously be attempting to cut back the call for. Thumbing down would not substitute the hypocrisy of prohibition. Alcohol and tobacco are some distance worse than marijuana, that could actual help human beings.

Answer 4

If your over 21 you can but the guy probably thought that the beer was for you so he didn't give it to him or your friend was to drunk it's happened to me before

Answer 5

I suspect the clerk was erring on the side of caution. He probably thought the adult was buying the booze for you and simply wanted to avoid problems.

Answer 6

What do people do who shop with their kids? Thats the most assanine thing i ever heard of.

Answer 7

New law, sucks right?

Answer 8

They were lying to you, there's nothing wrong with it.