Do You Agree That The Indian Government Should Offer Its Muslims, Incentives To Emigrate From India???

Question

Although India's Muslims are ONLY 12% of the Indian population, they constitute the world's second largest muslim population. A reality which is even more saddening when one considers the fact that they were all supposed to leave India in 1947 and that India should theoretically not have a single Muslim living there.

At the rate that they are breeding, estimates indicate that by 2050 they shall possibly be 50% of the Indian population. This will have catastrophic consequences for India's already depleted and underdeveloped resources, infrastructure. But more importantly it shall cause great social and religious conflict, a civil war with another masses of killings and may even possibly bring about another partition of the country.

Do you agree with me that it is about time the Indian government starts to introduce incentives for Muslims to emigrate from India, in an endeavour to preserve Hindu demographic predominance and to preclude any possible future genocides???

Answer 1

no we are democratic people living in worlds largest democratic and republic country we call ourseleves as one where all cast relegion is considered equal and its only country where many many relegions and different culture live togather with few differences. i say a big no

Answer 2

1) Quote the source of your "estimates".
2) Explain how even if theoritically muslims outnumber hindus will "This will have catastrophic consequences for India's already depleted and underdeveloped resources, infrastructure. But more importantly it shall cause great social and religious conflict, a civil war with another masses of killings and may even possibly bring about another partition of the country." WHAT ???
3) To make such serious allegations on such a platform you should have scientific sources at hand.
The country's best known atomic scientist is a muslim, the country's most patriotic song "SAARE JAHAN SE ACCHA ..." was penned by a muslim. The country's most successful cricket captain to date is a muslim. One of the wonders of the world was built by a muslim. the list is continous.
Muslims have not contributed a paisa to India's Economy ? What do you have to say ? Are muslims THE ONLY trouble makers in India rather the world , PROVE IT .

Answer 3

NO.
It is just by chance that one is born into a particular religion. Hinduism recognises this and says in all the scriptures that all prayers go to the same God; or that there is only one Truth, no matter what you name it; or that no-one should tell another what to worship, as every person's "shraddha" is given by God Himself. A true Hindu therefore respects all religions.

India is not a country of only Hindus. Several communities have lived here for centuries and contributed to make it the rich and varied culture it is today. India belongs equally to all these people.

Anybody who feels that someone who thinks differently should be persecuted is pathetically narrow-minded. Such thinking will not help this country to move forward to realise its true potential.

Answer 4

India is the only place where Muslims can progress without let or hindrance. They know this to be true. Most of them give too much importance on petty matters and waist their time and resources instead of concentrating on education for the poor amongst them. They should realise that knowledge is power and not fundamental muscle. Even if they emigrate what they will do for survival without skills. We should evolve a system by which their progress is also equal to other groups. I do not agree they should be made to emigrate from their own land INDIA which belongs to them as much as it to us.

Answer 5

First of all, we are all brothers and sisters in one way or the other if we check our tree line.
The earth is a place for Gods creation to leave in.
These boundaries are created by us humans to satisfy our worldly needs and power.

One more thing that I would like to mention is that before independence there were many Muslim rulers who ruled India, during their rule, people from other religions leaved happily and accepted them as their rulers. this is a historic example that Muslims are no threat to any society.

you cannot just push any one out from one country to another.
take an example of South Africa, after the fall of the white rule there are still many white people living in South Africa.
Or take example of Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Egypt you will find Coptic Christians(Christians for generations still leaving happily with the Arabs. So to you think they should be thrown out of these countries because these places are Majority Muslims

There are some Muslims who have roots from Hindu families
Do you want them to go some were else and break their family bonds.

Would you like to leave your father and mother and go to some other place? Or would you like to make your father and mother go somewhere else and not leave close to you, just because they are Muslim, Hindu, Christian or Sikh???
Think for your self

I leave in a Muslim country and work in an automotive company with a multi-religious environment, were my colleagues are Muslim, Christian and Hindu. We never had any problems, only difference of thoughts.

Answer 6

So you think INDIA belong to HINDU and not MUSLIM, suppose after some years Hindu remain in minority say 10 % then the majority may be muslim what should then they do to all Hindu, By the way HAN RAT LAX MAN, YOU ARE A MINORITY IN BRITAIN, LONDON, PL THROUGH YOURSELF AND FAMILY OUT OF LONDON AND COME BACK TO INDIA YOU HAVE MAJORITY IN INDIA.

Answer 7

if they want to go they are already allowed.
govt. should not offer anything like that in a secular country like india. they are part of india & should be treated as indian.

Answer 8

No. Other countries don't want them. The minority groups in UK and other lands are already causing far too much trouble.

India should sort out its own problems or reap the bad karma associated with its behaviour of its members.

Answer 9

No, not at all. My kind have already been on the receiving end of such treatment and believe me, it creates more problems than it solves.

Answer 10

No, i think they should all be put in one state like uttar pradesh. they should have passports to go to other states and pay huge taxes or stay in UP and make their own products and services besides weapons. They can do it but we hindus should also help them move their mosques from other states to UP free of cost and that includes Jama masjid.