Is it ever right to lie, and under what circumstances?

Answer 1

I think it is wrong to lie. But there is expedience. There is a proverb, the end justifies the means. There is a proverb, the end does not justify the means.

In judgment I think we always need to look at each action discretely, and then in context. To lie is to corrupt the record. We need the record to be accurate. An accurate record helps remove hypocrisy and promotes justice. So in discrete judgment it is always wrong to lie. In context of justification (justification is a kind of alchemy) we look at the outcome. Here I think there exists a protocol. If you are victimized by lies it may be OK to use lies not exceeding your base line environment. Your world view for example. If someone wants to entrap you unjustly by the alchemy of justification this seems to permit you some room to lie.

But this is escalation and it is our duty to lie as little as we can and to endure some harm for the preservation of the record. So I would say suffer as much as you can bear for the accuracy of the record.

Answer 2

Salam. there is not any Allah's words interior the Qur'an that muslim is ever authorized tolie decrease than any situation. we detect interior the Qur'an that Allah says we could constantly say the certainty (33:70).we could constantly shop away telling lie (22:30) we could no longer say what we did no longer do it (sixty one:2,3) we could no longer deceive Allah becuase it potential making cruelties to themselves (sixty one:7,8) based on the hadith we could telling a lie merely purely while (a million)we guard somebody who hides out that he/she would be able to be killed without solid reason (2)we practice the strategic of conflict to our enemies and (3)we guard an significant different who made quarrel for retaining the continuance of their marriage

Answer 3

in an ideal world of course it would not be right to lie, however, we do not live in an ideal world so exceptions have to made and the circumstnces in which exceptions have to be made are to numerous to be listed.
did people hiding jews in the second world war lie, yes.
have you ever lied to spare someones feelings the answer is probably yes,

Answer 4

Sure, when telling a lie would result in less harm than telling the truth.

Answer 5

The only case in which a lie is acceptable is when you are trying to protect you or a loved one.

They're called "white lies."

Answer 6

The only time it is not only right, but commendable, is if you do it to make harmony and peace between family, and friends, and to spare hurting another person. Otherwise it is definitely wrong.

Answer 7

It's acceptable to lie to people who are not members of your own race, religion or family ( unless you're acting as parent or caregiver ). government officials lie to their constituents with impunity, and do it regularly. After all, it's for your own good.....

Answer 8

Yes. Say a killer came in your house and demanded to know where your kids were hiding and you knew they were hiding in a safe place. Would you tell the killer?

Answer 9

if your wife is going to find out you cheated, you have to lie to spare her feelings, but if she is not going to find out then you should not lie.

Answer 10

Mostly everybody lies..it is part of our suvival mechanism.