should i do this fantasy trade??? please help quickly!!!!!?

Question

I get:
David Wright
Magglio Ordonez

He gets:
Grady Sizemore
Jose Reyes
Paul Konerko

who gets the better deal? help quick!!

Answer 1

keep konerko, you don't need to throw in a third if you're already giving up the best player. he should be giving you a third player to get reyes and grady.

Answer 2

I think you're giving up too much. Reyes will be Reyes all year which means you are pretty set at R's and SB's no matter who you surround him with. I also think Sizemore is better than David Wright. And Magglio Ordonez isn't doing as well with Sheff out of the lineup and the Tigers struggling. Do yourself a favor and look at recent stats; last month or two instead of season long stats and see how this trade looks. You don't want to give up hot guys(Konerko and Sizemore) for mild ones(Maggs and Wright).

Answer 3

This is the worst trade of all time. You're giving up a difference of about 50 sbs. Also, the power numbers between Wright and Ordonez and Sizemore and Konerko is about equal. You'll only be improving in avg. Horrible trade.

Answer 4

Depends mostly on what you need. If you are in need of mostly good batting average mixed in with power, do the trade. However, if you need stolen bases, do not do the trade. Overall, i would suggest not to do the trade since Konerko gives you power, Reyes gives you speed and Sizemore gives you both. Hope this helps!!

Answer 5

Don't do this trade. Konerko has been heating up and will give you homeruns. Reyes will get tons of steals and runs, and Sizemore is a five-tool talent who can give you homeruns and steals. David Wright is definetely a good 3B who can get you some steals as well as homers, and Magglio will give you a great batting average, but I think you're just giving up too much.

Answer 6

It's hard to say without seeing the rest of your team, but on the surface it looks awful lopsided in the other guy's favor.

So, don't do it. Reyes and Sizemore are top 10 players and both give you all-around numbers. Ordonez and Wright only give you average and power.

Answer 7

If you have to ask this question you should quit fantasy baseball altogether and the easy answer is Yes do it now!

Answer 8

hell no, why would you even consider doing that, you shouldnt even need to ask our help for that.

Answer 9

NO DONT GIVE UP REYES OR SIZEMORE

Answer 10

no