I have an idea for a book and i need you to tell me whether its a good idea?

Question

So this is the story line. There is a boy named jacob who lives the dream live. his family is rich. he goes to a private school. he has a girlfriend. but one day his parents mysteriously disappear. he is left with no money. he takes himself out of private school and enrolls in a public school because its cheaper. but he gets kicked out for fighting with his worst enemy. one day when hes out he finds a stray dog who he falls in love with. but then hurricane Katrina hits New Orleans and he and his dog who is the only thing he has left are seperated. im not gonna tell you anymore. do u think this would be a good idea for a story? would you read this book if it were on the shelves? what should i name the dog?

Answer 1

My first question is where is the realism? You could make it realistic, but I don't see it yet. You would have to consider this person's age when trying to make it realistic. Are you going for a Job story where nothing goes right for this kid? What is your theme? What lesson do you want your reader to learn? The premise or theme of the book doesn't have to be stated right out in the book, but it will help you unify the book and keep you from straying. Even Job had a premise/theme. God let Satan destroy everything for Job to prove that he was loyal to God no matter what? What is the point of putting your character through so much heart ache and disruption?

These are just some things to consider. You can make such a story work and I would read it. But don't be afraid to figure out some of these answers to solidify your story.

If you decide on a premise/theme, you can draw a name for the dog from that. Maybe your theme has to do with persevierance and you can name the dog Percy. I know that Percy is a bit lame, but maybe this will get your juices flowing.

Answer 2

The story line is not plausible. A young man under 18 would not be able to stay alone, nor live in a house, etc. if the parents were gone. Who would pay the mortgage, etc?
Maybe if you set him up with a foster family who put him in a public school it would work.
Name the dog Smitty.
Good luck with your book. Make sure and do an outline of the entire story to flesh out the beginning, middle and end.

Answer 3

Holy crap. the way the narrator says issues like, as I have been given used to calling it. in the commencing up I yet it would be greater powerful as a horror action picture, however the ideas quite do artwork. at cases it appears that evidently your itemizing issues off, or that it ought to apply some greater shape, yet whilst this grew to become right into a e book i might purchase it in a heart beat. the only ingredient that ought to make this undesirable as an entire e book is whether or no longer that's a sort of large long books. yet whilst it is saved at approximately 5 or 6 hundred pages, this may be outstanding. the ideas are so unique, this may be the suited set up for a sequel, the place you come across out the full grasp plot of the sequence. you're quite going someplace with this. yet, that's in basic terms my opinion. so, ya comprehend.

Answer 4

Totally youre killing me what happens to him?
The dogs name should be katrina as a prelude to the storm thats gonna hit or maybe something like loyal or something. Dont make him under 18 make him in college but he has to switch out because once his parents disapear his money runs out and he has to go the state college get him kicked out for breaking some guys something or other and then continue.

Answer 5

I do like this storyline!! However, I suggest explaining why the parents disappeared - They were murdered or died somehow, and due to legalities he couldn't get a hold of the money. I think you should name the dog Hope, or Miracle or something to signify his importance. I would definitely read this book if it were on the shelves!!!

Answer 6

OMG!!! that is so original. i hope you elaborate on the whole "public school, find a dog" thing it could get confusing. i'm trying to write a story myself. i hope i can find ideas.. name the dog estelle, sophie, stella, or rose, or roxxii. you have to know what kind of personality you want the dog to have, then form a name around it. the names i said are names i like the best

Answer 7

wow thts a good idea but i wouldnt trust the internet that much someone is v. likely to steal this idea as its v. good yes i would read it if it was on the shelves i love that you left a cliffhanger it makes me want to know what happens next a good idea for the end of a chapter as it makes you want to read on hmmm.... i can't help you with the dogs name im not that good with naming things but ill let you know if i do think of anything

Answer 8

You have an awesome start... Not too sure if you should have made it public, only because I don't want somene else taking your idea... But it seems like you are on the right track! I wish I had the talent to write a book!

Good Luck!!!!

Answer 9

from a realistic point of view, it isn't realistic. Where does he live? On the street?

Anyway, ideas are a dime a dozen. Whatever you come up with, its been done before. The main thing is that it is something that fires your creative juices. The idea is the easy part, the writing of it is the challenge.

Answer 10

honestly, and i hope you want honesty, this idea has been done before but in different variations. Sometimes the dog is a girl, sometimes its the parents. If you can change it into something people havent seen yet then i say go for it. as for naming the dog, i have no idea.